Value of: Edler to MTL

[NuxFan09]

Edler isn't a top-pair dmen on any team

Yes he is.

 

[PetterssonSimp]

Juulsen and a 2017 2nd for Edler?

Don't feel he's a better prospect than Juolevi. I'd have rather dealt Edler at the draft and taken my own guy than made this weak deal.

From what i read Benning wants a top 6 winger in any deal for Edler, So Juulsen doesn't do any thing for Vancouver Detroit could offer Nyquist+Detroit's 2nd round pick for Edler that fills more of a need for Benning then adding futures in Juulsen.

Just as weak as above. We filled out left handed top 6 winger role already, Canucks need a right handed shooter to play RW on the 2nd line IMHO. Also anything with Edler out would make me want at least a PK specialist left side guy who isn't signed for more than the year and isn't above Edler's 5 million cap hit. Neither of these I'd look to Detroit for.

I'd wave Scherbak around. But don't expect us to give up a proven top 6 forward for Edler. It'd be a step backward. It's exactly what this team has spent all their effort into improving.

Still not enough. Just because there's incentive for you to do the deal and get a top defender doesn't mean the Canucks will accept a deal based on lesser pieces with no gain in draft picks worthy of dealing Edler off the defence.

 

[Legend123]

edler is old and regressing, injury prone and limited offense in him. No, Habs should stay quite clear from him. Do you suggest we go with a top 4 containing edler (30) weber (31) and markov (37)??

 

[jacks*]

Juulsen and a 2017 2nd for Edler?

That would be the absolute most i would offer for Edler.