StevenToddIves
Registered User
Please don't take this wrong, but posts like these are extremely troubling without offering a hint of explanation.Cooley could very well end up being the better overall player but the Devil's should definitely take Slavkovsky over Cooley. I think the points maybe don't show it, but Cooley I think is the far superior player to Nazar for example. His game I think is much more projectable to the next level. Cooley won't bust, Nazar has a decent chance to bust
I love the Cooley v Nazar debate because it's so close. They're similar sized and both elite skaters. Cooley gets the edge in skating because he's a bit more explosive in his acceleration and has remarkable top speed. Cooley gets a slight edge as a playmaker, but again Nazar possesses terrific vision and it's close. But I think that's everywhere I give the edge to Cooley.
Nazar is a slightly superior shooter, especially because of an almost preternatural ability to change his shot angle at the last second. Despite being just 5'10-175, Nazar is actually more physical and loves to buzz-saw his way through the interior. While Cooley prefers to circle up high looking for seams to pass through for high-danger chances, Nazar is less predictable in that he also loves to use his quick hands and high-end sticklhandling to knife towards the net himself. Nazar fears nothing, and I'd rank his compete level among the highest in the 2022 draft -- while Cooley's is very good, it's not at Nazar's level. Nazar is also the better defensive player and more versatile -- having played a great deal of right wing (Cooley just center) and on the US-NTDP top PP and PK unit (Cooley is top PP but scarcely used on the PK).
I strongly, strongly disagree that Nazar has "a decent chance to bust". His versatility allows him the talent floor of an outstanding 3rd liner, while Cooley needs a top 6 role to succeed. And, as I often say -- players with high intangibles (compete & IQ) have the highest chance of approaching their talent ceiling, and Nazar's intangibles are among the best in the 2022 draft class.
Both Logan Cooley and Frank Nazar are exciting and dynamic players. But I have Nazar at #5 and Cooley at #6, and although it's close, I'm sticking with it. One of my major reasons for ranking Nazar so highly is that I feel he has as scarce a chance to "bust" as almost anyone in the 2022 class. You can play him anywhere, in any situation, at any time. He's a coaches (and linemates) dream. He's a guy you put out there whether up by one goal or down by one goal late in the game. The kid's a winner.