Idk what there is to 'holy crap man' for - Siegenthaler will not be playing the same minutes as Luke Hughes. Not even close. Therefore it does matter who the top pair is
You can keep saying fit but that 'fit' had a single season of sample size under a different coach in our greatest regular season ever - the odds of that replicating are slim to none
I see absolutely no reason why Nemec and Siegenthaler cant play together
The holy crap man is you not really reading/comprehending remotely what I’ve saying. Even if Siegenthaler is playing with Dougie on what is listed as the top pair, he won’t playing as many minutes as Luke. That’s literally my whole point. Therefore it doesn’t matter in the slightest who’s listed as the top pair.
He already played 2 minutes less per game than Luke this year despite being listed on the top pair most of the time. That will likely be an even bigger difference if he still sucks and we bring in someone better than Bahl and Smith such as Dillon.
The fit wasn’t just about that one season. I don’t want Nemec with Siegenthaler. When they’ve played together, Siegenthaler is either not giving Nemec the puck and just throwing it up the wall or he’s sending him tougher to deal with and rimmed D2D’s. Nemec isn’t that great at dealing with those and Siegenthaler doesn’t really help get him the puck in good spots and play to his strengths. I think a better, more experienced D partner who hopefully doesn’t do that as much will be better for Nemec.
And I think Dougie is very good at playing with Siegenthaler. Even when Siegs has been bad, Dougie plays a pretty simple game himself and seems pretty adept and comfortable at taking any shitty rims or passes he might be getting from him and dealing with them. He’s much better at doing so than Nemec and I want Nemec to have a partner than can help him flourish not potentially drag him down.