@MVP Zacha
In response to your post in the Wood thread, which I've moved here, so to not derail the Wood thread.
And I'm sure if he sucks again it'll be ''Oh, he's still injured!'' or ''Oh but he finally started to turn the corner the last 10 games of the season with his .930% in that span! Who cares about the first 20-30 games he played where he was an .895%!''.
I've seen this movie before with Cory and that's why I still have a stick up my ass about that and am admittedly incredibly pompous and arrogant over it.
By the way, I do give him a better chance than I ever gave Cory just because he's 25 and not 32-33, but I still think there's a pretty good chance that he's not a particularly good goalie.
But goalies get overrated. That's why when one has a BIG game (remember Ben Scrivens 800 save shutout?) or even a big streak, you hear about it for a very long time. Just like the CLOWN that played here for 7-8 games or whatever it was a few months ago. That stupid FLUKE streak he had in 2015. Kevin Weekes couldn't stop talking about how great Mike Condon was, only less than two years before he washed out of the league for good.
You can say goalies get underrated by me or that I give them too short a leash, but really there's actually a contingent that gives them more rope than they should get. They also get more points when they play on a stacked team even if they aren't all that great. Is Jordan Binnington still elite? Remember when Martin Jones was elite or at the very least considered ''Good'' because the Sharks made the playoffs all the time and a Stanley Cup Finals and another conference finals? Of course Chris Osgood got the opposite treatment of this, as did Corey Crawford during his career. And then you see all these guys getting deals after bad season after bad season. Craig Anderson is 41 and hasn't had a good season in 5 years and keeps getting deals. Brian Elliott keeps getting signed despite sucking everywhere he played that wasn't St. Louis. A team that aspires to win the cup just traded for Matt Murray's young but charred cremains and signed non-tendered RFA Samsonov as the safety net. I could really go on and on with those examples.
In the end, Blackwood was a solid goalie before these problems started, but he was never Cory Schneider or even as good as Shesterkin or Sorokin have looked since coming into the league. And that mediocre AHL resume happened before covid, before injuries. He had maybe one average season in the AHL, which was his rookie year. Then an astronomically bad one and then a below average one. The argument after the really bad 17-18 AHL season was there's not really a list of goalies that went on to have a successful NHL career after a year like that in the minors. I wasn't one of the people arguing that. I didn't participate in those arguments. Just observed them, but that argument is looking like it could prove true.
Carter Hart has also had a miserable last two years as well, but also has a much higher ceiling. At the same time, that higher ceiling may not be met and the fact that he was rushed (hello Nico Daws!) into the league earlier than he should have been might cost him a better career or at least sort of make him a very late bloomer in the way Marc Andre Fleury was.