Devils team discussion (news, notes and speculation) - offseason part II

Status
Not open for further replies.

JimEIV

Registered User
Feb 19, 2003
67,701
30,526
Kevin Fiala 283 points in 419 games . 675 PPG - 55.35 Point Pace

Jesper Bratt 203 points in 307 games .661 PPG - 54.22 Point Pace
I know every MFer in this entire HF universe is currently double checking these numbers...I had to twice it was so unbelievable.
 

Stephen Gionta

Boston College > Boston University
Jun 15, 2015
6,392
2,487
East Rutherford, NJ
But if you want us to play along with the simply looking at points game, lets do it:

Brady Tkachuk 3 seasons before signing his big contract.
18-19: 22 goals, 45 points, 71 games. 52 point pace.
19-20: 21 goals, 44 points, 71 games. 50 point pace
20-21: 17 goals, 36 points, 56 games. 53 point pace.

Jesper Bratt in those three seasons:
18-19: 8 goals, 33 points, 51 games. 53 point pace.
19-20: 16 goals, 32 points, 60 games. 43 point pace.
20-21: 7 goals, 30 points, 46 games. 53 point pace.


So yeah, I'd love to know where this notion that "Jesper Bratt is a MUCH Better overall player than Brady Tkachuk. In basically every aspect of the sport" is coming from....
 
  • Like
Reactions: NjdevilfanJim

Zajacs Bowl Cut

Lets Go Baby
Nov 6, 2005
72,970
47,097
PA
But if you want us to play along with the simply looking at points game, lets do it:

Brady Tkachuk 3 seasons before signing his big contract.
18-19: 22 goals, 45 points, 71 games. 52 point pace.
19-20: 21 goals, 44 points, 71 games. 50 point pace
20-21: 17 goals, 36 points, 56 games. 53 point pace.

Jesper Bratt in those three seasons:
18-19: 8 goals, 33 points, 51 games. 53 point pace.
19-20: 16 goals, 32 points, 60 games. 43 point pace.
20-21: 7 goals, 30 points, 46 games. 53 point pace.


So yeah, I'd love to know where this notion that "Jesper Bratt is a MUCH Better overall player than Brady Tkachuk. In basically every aspect of the sport" is coming from....

Tkachuk is an atrocious defensive player while Bratt is passable, and Bratt is better offensively....?

EVEN if you were to tell me that they are on the same level (they are not), that would mean Bratt should get $8 million longterm then right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: glenwo2 and Blender

Stephen Gionta

Boston College > Boston University
Jun 15, 2015
6,392
2,487
East Rutherford, NJ
Tkachuk is an atrocious defensive player while Bratt is passable, and Bratt is better offensively....?

EVEN if you were to tell me that they are on the same level (they are not), that would mean Bratt should get $8 million longterm then right?

I love Jesper Bratt, but players like Brady Tkachuk are unicorns in the game today. They're just so so valuable and I don't know how you can deny that and call yourself a knowledgeable fan at the same time.
 

Jersey Fan 12

Positive Vibes
Nov 20, 2006
7,170
3,113
Easy to argue that Bratt has been way more consistent than Nico or Jack ever have.

If you're strictly talking points in 2022-23, you're right.

However, through three coaches Bratt has found himself on the bench (and at times in the press box) due to inconsistent or disinterested play in the other areas of the game.

Unlike the other two, he is unable (or unwilling) to do things like defend, forecheck or kill penalties when his speed suggests he could be effective in that part of the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BurntToast

Zajacs Bowl Cut

Lets Go Baby
Nov 6, 2005
72,970
47,097
PA
I love Jesper Bratt, but players like Brady Tkachuk are unicorns in the game today. They're just so so valuable and I don't know how you can deny that and call yourself a knowledgeable fan at the same time.

again I think that because of his last name and who is brother and dad are, that Brady gets very overrated. He is a nice player. He is NOT a "unicorn" or any kind of elite player.

If you're strictly talking points in 2022-23, you're right.

However, through three coaches Bratt has found himself on the bench (and at times in the press box) due to inconsistent or disinterested play in the other areas of the game.

Unlike the other two, he is unable (or unwilling) to do things like defend, forecheck or kill penalties when his speed suggests he could be effective in that part of the game.

what lol

and yeah, that elite penalty killer, Jack Hughes!!
 

RSeen

Registered User
Oct 26, 2011
6,788
2,151
Toronto
I think they're much more inclined to open up the checkbook and give Bratt a long term deal next year:

1.) Much more cap space
2.) Coming off two good years makes it easier to commit
3.) Eats up more UFA years

It'll cost more to do a long term deal next year but I think we'll not only be more eager to pay him more, but feel much more safe about doing it.

Obviously they both know where each other stand on a long term deal. I think this arbitration is more of a "franchise tag" year than anything else, just buying time to get the real deal worked out.
It's way too risky to think like this. He'd be one year from UFA.

He needs to be locked up long-term now, can't wait a year. If we are in this situation next year, we are going to be forced to trade him.
 

HersheyBob27

Registered User
Apr 5, 2014
2,109
796
Canada
Why? Because I actually believe in the player and if you get him for 8 on a long term deal, that will be a savings compared to what he’ll get in UFA. If you don’t believe in the player, fine. I do. He was our best player last season and I wouldn’t be at all surprised if he is again.
Glad you aren’t our GM 🙄
 

JimEIV

Registered User
Feb 19, 2003
67,701
30,526
But if you want us to play along with the simply looking at points game, lets do it:

Brady Tkachuk 3 seasons before signing his big contract.
18-19: 22 goals, 45 points, 71 games. 52 point pace.
19-20: 21 goals, 44 points, 71 games. 50 point pace
20-21: 17 goals, 36 points, 56 games. 53 point pace.

Jesper Bratt in those three seasons:
18-19: 8 goals, 33 points, 51 games. 53 point pace.
19-20: 16 goals, 32 points, 60 games. 43 point pace.
20-21: 7 goals, 30 points, 46 games. 53 point pace.


So yeah, I'd love to know where this notion that "Jesper Bratt is a MUCH Better overall player than Brady Tkachuk. In basically every aspect of the sport" is coming from....
I honestly don't think enough is made out players that can stay in the lineup...Between Nico and Jack this is becoming a real problem for us...But look at those games played difference between Jesper and Brady...Now I like Jesper. I am of the inclination to pay him big dollars...

But pacing the record to erase missed time is kind of statistical sleight of hand....This is not insignificant.

71 games > 51
71 games > 60 * we only played 69 games this season
56 games > 46
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stephen Gionta
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad