Devils team discussion (news, notes and speculation) - offseason edition

Status
Not open for further replies.

Nico Hischier

Registered User
Nov 22, 2017
3,141
2,857
What would you offer nichushkin if he gets to UFA? We are probably low on his wish list and would have to overpay to get him to come to nj and I’m sure he will get lots of offers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdj12784

Unknown Caller

Registered User
Apr 30, 2009
10,332
7,975
Why in the world are we trying to trade Holtz after we've already invested 2 years into his development and he is NHL ready? Trading a draft pick is one thing, but he should be NHL ready next year. He is coming off a productive year as well so this makes no sense.

Keep Holtz and our 2nd pick. We have the opportunity to have an elite team in a few years with having all this young talent on the roster but several potential players on ELC's. Make the right short-term additions, and this team can be elite.

What has led you to believe that Alex Holtz is NHL ready next year aside from hype?

Nobody is questioning whether he’s a high end prospect, but the fact that you “invested 2 years developing him” isn’t a reason to make him untouchable. I think a lot of fans severely overrate Alex Holtz. He should be 100% moveable in the right deal. He’s not a can’t miss no-brainer prospect and he can bring a lot of value back.

Again, it has to be in the right deal for an elite piece back.
 
Last edited:

glenwo2

JESPER BRATWURST
Oct 18, 2008
52,557
25,118
New Jersey(No Fanz!)
It's do or die for playoffs or else the front office is gone next offseason. That's more what I mean...

I'm also not putting Holtz in the Top 6 in October, maybe March if he's earned. Don't underestimate Mercer.
You really think Harris and Blitzer give two s--ts about what Fitz is or isn't doing as GM of the Devils right now?

They're more concerned with buying the friggin' Denver Broncos than the NJ Devils right now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Patrik26

RangerDoggo

The Devils have a culture of failure
Feb 3, 2016
3,166
2,592
Brooklyn via NJ, like the Nets
You really think Harris and Blitzer give two s--ts about what Fitz is or isn't doing as GM of the Devils right now?

They're more concerned with buying the friggin' Denver Broncos than the NJ Devils right now.
Don't forget Chelsea. But frankly I'd rather have owners that just write the checks than overly meddlesome creeps.
 

glenwo2

JESPER BRATWURST
Oct 18, 2008
52,557
25,118
New Jersey(No Fanz!)
Don't forget Chelsea. But frankly I'd rather have owners that just write the checks than overly meddlesome creeps.
Oh me, too.

I don't like Jerry Jones types.

But my point is that someone saying that it's Playoffs or management gets replaced....and I'm like "The people who can fire Management are the owners who are more concerned with owning an NFL (and Euro-Futbol) team than anything Fitz does with NJ Devils.



I forgot he even existed. No joke.
 

Its Always Sundstrom

Among the optimists.
Sponsor
Dec 1, 2019
5,329
11,430
Holtz straight up for a time machine which could take us back to 1993, where we could grab 21 year old Marty Brodeur and bring him back to the present.
It’s going to take me a bit!

Damn, where’s that kid? Damn, damn.

Marty!?!?
 

Attachments

  • 07C9D7F5-445B-4031-A241-F81235BDAD37.png
    07C9D7F5-445B-4031-A241-F81235BDAD37.png
    148.2 KB · Views: 2

Its Always Sundstrom

Among the optimists.
Sponsor
Dec 1, 2019
5,329
11,430
someone could piss right into zacha's bowl of cornflakes as he was eating it and he would turn and skate away and not care.

6' 3" .... 210 use the size...show something


...more like spinal tap 16" stonehenge ....
My mom never allowed me to wear my skates at the breakfast table. Lucky son of…
 

Saugus

Ecrasez l'infame!
Sponsor
Jun 17, 2009
105,808
14,023
Connecticut
What has led you to believe that Alex Holtz is NHL ready next year aside from hype?

Nobody is questioning whether he’s a high end prospect, but the fact that you “invested 2 years developing him” isn’t a reason to make him untouchable. I think a lot of fans severely overrate Alex Holtz. He should be 100% moveable in the right deal. He’s not a can’t miss no-brainer prospect and he can bring a lot of value back.

Again, it has to be in the right deal for an elite piece back.

Holtz isn't untouchable, but I doubt management would let him go without giving him another shot to play his way into our top 6. Holtz is rightly rated highly because of how he has played at the AHL level, and we'll want to see if that translates. It hasn't yet, given how lost he looked in his NHL call ups this season, but think he will at least get a chance to play his way onto the roster in camp.

If, at that time, he is clearly getting passed on the depth chart by our existing wingers or anybody we might draft, sign or trade for this summer, then you look to move him as part of a package for an upgrade at another position of need. But not before.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OlfactoryHughes

Triumph

Registered User
Oct 2, 2007
14,029
14,987
Holtz isn't untouchable, but I doubt management would let him go without giving him another shot to play his way into our top 6. Holtz is rightly rated highly because of how he has played at the AHL level, and we'll want to see if that translates. It hasn't yet, given how lost he looked in his NHL call ups this season, but think he will at least get a chance to play his way onto the roster in camp.

If, at that time, he is clearly getting passed on the depth chart by our existing wingers or anybody we might draft, sign or trade for this summer, then you look to move him as part of a package for an upgrade at another position of need. But not before.

Nah, this is bad. I don't think the Devils should looking to move Holtz, but the time to trade him is now. If he starts to stumble next year and spends significant time in the AHL, his value has already decreased big-time. A guy theoretically unable to crack the roster of a rebuilding team after having that kind of season in the minors, there's big red flags there.
 

FooteBahl

Took a big shitz for Nemec
Jul 19, 2005
5,491
7,530
Metuchen NJ
Nah, this is bad. I don't think the Devils should looking to move Holtz, but the time to trade him is now. If he starts to stumble next year and spends significant time in the AHL, his value has already decreased big-time. A guy theoretically unable to crack the roster of a rebuilding team after having that kind of season in the minors, there's big red flags there.
The kid is still 7 months away from being able to drink legally in the states. This isn’t Zacha we’re talking about. Don’t dismiss the Covid effect on a lot of these guys and losing prime developmental time. He possesses a trait with his shot that this team sorely needs and he should be given a long leash to prove himself.
 

Unknown Caller

Registered User
Apr 30, 2009
10,332
7,975
Holtz isn't untouchable, but I doubt management would let him go without giving him another shot to play his way into our top 6. Holtz is rightly rated highly because of how he has played at the AHL level, and we'll want to see if that translates. It hasn't yet, given how lost he looked in his NHL call ups this season, but think he will at least get a chance to play his way onto the roster in camp.

If, at that time, he is clearly getting passed on the depth chart by our existing wingers or anybody we might draft, sign or trade for this summer, then you look to move him as part of a package for an upgrade at another position of need. But not before.

You have to give to get. If the Devils are targeting elite players, you need to include valuable pieces in a package back. My point is that Holtz may be one of those prime pieces, and he’s moveable.

It has nothing to do with moving him because of his development or because he’s passed over, and everything to do with the potential pieces you could include in an appealing trade package.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdj12784
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Ad

Ad