It was during the 18-19 season that I figured Hynes wouldn't be fired at any point until the next year, due to all the comments from Hall about how much he loved him and him coming up on the end of his contract. That was my thinking at the time and the rationale for why Hynes probably wasn't going anywhere until the next season (or until we knew Hall's fate) at that point.
But now looking back on it, no matter if we wanted Hynes gone or not, he almost definitely wasn't going to get fired the year after making the playoffs. Hall could have demanded a trade in the 2018 offseason and Hynes probably would have been back to at least start the 19-20 season.
But yes, he really should have been fired as soon as that desperation move of sending Fitz to the bench happened. I don't understand what that was supposed to do, but it was clear that Hynes was definitely getting close to the end, but they really should have been the end of him. And that's why I say Hynes probably only overstayed his welcome by about 7 weeks or however many weeks it was before the Fitz to the bench stuff, which looks like it was 7 weeks roughly.
Hynes first got a 3 year deal with an extra option for the 2018-19 season. They announced he got the 4th year in Feb 2018.
Hynes then got a multi-year extension that started in 2019-20 which was announced on Jan 3rd 2019. Hynes was kind of hanging on a thread considering he entered the season a lame duck.
The team was 15-16-7 but coming off a 4-2-0 stretch. (That little run included a 3 game winning streak! Get excited!) We then ended up going 16-24-3 and never won more than two games in a row.
Hall’s last game that season was on Dec 23 2018.
“Multi-year” turns out to reportedly be two years, according to this Tweet.
So again, not a massive amount of enthusiasm but Shero did take forever to finally fire him. I’m guessing in part because he just extended him. Which is why I don’t think Fitz sticks with Ruff. One lame duck year doesn’t give him much time before Fitz has to extend or fire him.
Having Ruff coach the season out as dead man walking, without ever extending him, would give us a very downbeat coach.