- May 1, 2011
- 136,541
- 67,682
Marty gave up a lot of softy marshmallow goals due to his style of play. When Marty first broke into the league those were common on more goalies in the league than not. Especially really early on in his career when most of the goalies in the league were still-stand up goalies. As we got into the new millennium, there weren't many guys playing that style anymore. There were times like the 2001 playoffs (particularly the cup finals) where Marty was legitimately bad and looked fried. I felt like he looked like that a lot the year/playoffs following a long playoff run. His 01-02 regular season was pretty weak after those two long playoff runs. For prime Marty, that wasn't a very good season from him. His 03-04 was really good, but he gave up some really bad ones in the 2004 series against the Flyers and I'm pretty sure his second half of that season he was breaking down a bit. He was on pace for like 15 or 16 shutouts that year by January and a record number of shutouts in a year, but then he wound up only having 2 more shutouts (I think?) the rest of that year and finishing with like 11.The security guard at my dad’s office building when I was growing up used to call Brodeur “Marty the Marshmallow” because he gave up too many soft goals. Goes to show that a fanbase basically always thinks their goalie sucks regardless of how good they are.
With that said, our goalies since prime Schneider have legitimately sucked.
One time Marty got more shit than he deserved was the 2009 series against the Hurricanes, where he was legitimately good, other than the series winning goal and one other bad, leaky, 7-hole goal earlier in that game (to Ruutu lol), but he was lights out that series. He was actually better in that series than a couple of the series where he won, like the Tampa series two years before that. The 2008 Rangers series, as well as the 2010 Flyers series (his decline had already begun by that series) were really bad.
I'm still not happy at the heat he took in 2009. He may have even taken more heat at the time than WORTHLESS JUNIOR LEAGUE head coach Brent Sutter did, at least at that time he did. And washed up sacks of shit like Colin White, Jay Pandolfo and John Madden didn't really get the heat they deserved.