- May 8, 2010
- 23,051
- 40,967
Good list, I agree with most of this as my list is fairly similar. Having 2 of arguably the top 3 D-men prospects is awesome. Especially since they haven’t even joined full time yet. Good times ahead with Luke and Simon.Right now, off the top of my head I'd rank the top 20:
1 Bedard CHI
2 Michkov PHI
3 Fantilli CLB
4 Hughes NJ
5 Carlsson ANH
6 Jiricek CLB
7 Nemec NJ
8 Slafkovsky MTL
9 Cooley ARI
10 Edvinsson DET
11 Benson BUF
12 Wright SEA
13 Smith SJ
14 Gauthier PHI
15 Simashev ARI
16 Reinbacher MTL
17 Faber MIN
18 Leonard WSH
19 Dvorsky STL
20 Clarke LAK
I have Hughes as the top D and Nemec as the #3 D, so the Devils still probably have a top 10 prospect pool overall until Hughes graduates next season.
I’m struggling with Jiricek/Nemec. They’re close, but Nemec’s end to the season and 5v5 scoring sways me his way right now. Jiricek got the vast majority of his points on the PP this year, while Nemec got limited time. I also tend to value elite skating, transition play and high IQ with offensive D-men and I feel Nemec fits this description better. Jiricek has the better shot and is more physical though.