I must agree with with
@Out of Business here. I think the myth that Johnsson is a top-flight second liner and Anderson is some future 4th-line grinder is just silly. I think Anderson will be a pretty good third-liner this year, if Toronto chooses to give him those minutes.
Ultimately, I have said I don't hate the deal, simply because Johnsson makes the Devils better right now, and the first round draft picks of both Holtz and Mercer clearly affected Anderson's status on the Devils depth chart. But we also need to face the fact that what Johnsson is right now -- a good and well-rounded third-line LW with the requisite offensive pop to slot up to an offensive line -- is something which is clearly attainable by Joey Anderson in the very near future.
Anderson is already a very good defensive player, and his compete level and hockey IQ are both excellent. His offensive presence seemed to increase with the more ice time and experience he received, both at the AHL level and in brief stints with the Devils. I would not be surprised if Anderson were the superior player to Johnsson by the end of the 2021-22 season.
It won't happen because the Leafs are deeper at RW than LW, but if Anderson were given regular minutes with Matthews or Tavares like Johnsson has received, I feel he would blow away Johnsson's point production
this year. 21 points in 43 games on that high-octane Leafs team has to be concerning, injury or no.
But while dispelling the myths of Johnsson being better than he is or Anderson being some no-upside grinder, we also must understand that Fitzgerald needed a LW to play a middle six role, and a top six role in case of injury to Bratt or ineffectiveness by Boqvist -- who I still hold out hope to crack the 2020-21 roster as the 2nd line LW. Johnsson has the ability to slot up the line-up at LW right now, and he is also a complete player who gives you a good 200-foot game and some net-front presence.
So, right now it looks like not a great deal, not a terrible one. I don't think the Devils should have given up a player of Anderson's quality who now becomes a top-3 forward prospect in Toronto behind only Amirov and Robertson. Toronto is still over the cap, and Johnsson is a useful player, but not exactly a guy who teams would be lining up for. I think they would have given him for less.
But again, the Devils drafted two RWs in the top 18 picks this year, and acquired a player stylistically similar to Anderson with Nick Merkley. So they could afford to give him up in order to improve right now, and this is certainly defendable logic. I do agree with you wholeheartedly that the myth should be dispelled that Johnsson is somehow a far superior offensive talent to Anderson, because it's probably not the case.