Here is the thing a prospect being traded for a rental…they are likely a prospect that is going to bust. Teams know their players better than other teams and they probably know better who is more likely to make it than not.
Devils 2021-22 team discussion (news, notes and speculation) - part XII
- Thread starter njdevils1982
- Start date
- Status
Here is the thing a prospect being traded for a rental…they are likely a prospect that is going to bust. Teams know their players better than other teams and they probably know better who is more likely to make it than not.
The Wumpus
bottomless pit supervisor
Guadana
Registered User
The Wumpus
bottomless pit supervisor
How many from recent years? How many for pure rentals? How many for the level of rentals we have?
We traded Hall as a top level rental in 2019-20 and so far the only impactful piece back was the pick (Mercer). Maybe you can argue Merkley as he was part of the Graves trade, but That’s a stretch.
Guadana
Registered User
Merkley is a part for Jaros as i remember.
I can check tommorow more, but the first one what come to mind is Kuokkanen.
And Kouk is a net negative player this year and probably won’t be on the team next year.
If you got a type guy the team in question can sign long term you can good prospect. Otherwise take the lottery ticket.
Dylan9z9
LGD 2024-25
All that being said The Devils are usually near the cap floor ... probably had to get Dougie Hamilton to keep from falling below it.
Guadana
Registered User
Who will replace him? If he will not be with the team - if only we will trade him for a better player.
So your rule doesn`t work. It`s a second year slump. Nothing more. You cant judge him by his sloopy 2nd season 35 games.
And it was a good trade. Easy yes any day any time than another 3-4 round picks.
We got two pp because of him today btw. You are using bad argument.
SKNJD9
Hi, I'm mat.
Dylan9z9
LGD 2024-25
Jack Be Quick
Hasek Is Right
I'm just learning about this situation now and you're not wrong.
But high school football culture in the South, Midwest, and anywhere else where it is intrinsic to the towns identity are just as bad if not worse.
See: Wall Township, NJ.
Former NHLer Reid Boucher pleads guilty to lesser charge in sexual assault case
"The survivor, now 23, says she has dealt with severe trauma, self-harm and substance abuse issues since the incident and is “disgusted” by the judge’s reasoning, according to the Detroit Free Press.
“I feel like a lot of the progress I’ve made over the last 10 years — that’s been undone,” she said."
This makes me sick. And yeah, I'm aware he was a 'kid' too, but we're talking about a 12 y/o here.
This motherf***er needs to do time
The Wumpus
bottomless pit supervisor
Schedule quirk: at the end of the season, Detroit visits us twice, non-consecutively, on the same road trip.
glenwo2
JESPER BRATWURST
It depends on the quality of the player. Claude Giroux will return a high end prospect. Andy Greene will return the guys which are likely to bust.
Giroux is not going to command a high level prospect at the deadline. I would bet any prospect that is in a deal for him won’t amount to much. That is if a prospect is even involved. They will probably just get a first for him.
NJDevs26
Once upon a time...
- Mar 21, 2007
- 68,547
- 34,136
I'm guessing those smiles turned into frowns later on after tonight's debacle.
Talk is cheap but yea, pretty much
Unknown Caller
Registered User
- Apr 30, 2009
- 10,332
- 7,975
Better Call Sal
Salnalysis
Sadly, this is what the people who run these accounts are paid to do.
Our account does the same thing.
SJinNewJersey
Every single one of us, the devil inside
Mercer is a pretty big piece, and we also have Bahl to show for that trade as well. Maltsev was in the Graves deal, Merkley (aka Booger) went to SJ for Jaros. Additionally, we also got a 3rd round pick from Arizona in that deal that Fitz turned in to Jonas Siegenthaler. I would say that Siegenthaler has made quite an impact on this team this year.
- Apr 20, 2005
- 2,796
- 1,796
This is the point that @jkrdevil was making. The picks ended up turning into the most value in return for Hall. 1st (Mercer) and 3rd (Siegs). Vs Bahl, Merkley, Schnarr. The Hall trade was known as a pu pu platter at the time, so it's not entirely fair, but it's still true.
I would love to find a prospect that could blossom into a star here. But, in the cap world, it's more likely to find Siegs or Palms available for futures than someone will trade Iginla for Nieuwendyk again.
SJinNewJersey
Every single one of us, the devil inside
No he wasn't, he said "so far the only impactful piece back was the pick (Mercer).", so what does that make Siegenthaler? He's not impactful. Please.
- Status
