Detroit Redwings Downfall

thebestnic

Registered User
Jun 29, 2022
372
605
Tell me you don't have any clue what you're talking about without telling my you have no clue what you're talking about.

You are an OTT fan? You do realize Edvinsson is better than Sanderson? Are you saying Sanderson isn't a "player of substance"?
He's better than Sanderson because ?? Because you said so ?
 

GhostfaceWu

Shi Shaw
Feb 11, 2015
11,266
11,755
They've never addressed the 2c. Can't have Kane being centered by coop. Should have made a real run at necas when they were talking about trading him.
 

nbwingsfan

Registered User
Dec 13, 2009
22,252
16,425
Yzerman's "ok lets get competitive finally" signings all turned out to be bad, basically. They propelled the Red Wings out of the 9th circle of hell into purgatory at significant cost. Guys like Copp, Chiarot. Holl etc just ended up being terrible and also expensive.
So they’re all both terrible AND single handedly winning us games…?
 

voyageur

Hockey fanatic
Jul 10, 2011
10,426
9,745
Missing the two best Michigan born players?

Haven't watched a Wings game since the Jets beat them, so I'm not qualified to comment on them. Defense seems like it could use a Sergachev in the top 3. Maybe that's in the future?

Husso was a curious signing. One good year really. When does the Cossa era arrive?

Are Copp and Compher good enough top 6 players to propel the Wings into a playoff spot? Seems like if or when the young guys push them down to 3rd line players the Wings will be competitive again.
 

Pavels Dog

Registered User
Feb 18, 2013
20,792
16,551
Sweden
Haven't watched a Wings game since the Jets beat them, so I'm not qualified to comment on them. Defense seems like it could use a Sergachev in the top 3. Maybe that's in the future?

Husso was a curious signing. One good year really. When does the Cossa era arrive?
Cossa is rocking the AHL's 2nd best Sv% and GAA (min 10GP).
If he keeps anything close to this up you'll see him in NHL games this season and he might be on the NHL roster next season.

As for the defense, Edvinsson/Seider/Pellikka is the core. Wallinder and Buium are probably the highest potential of the "B" prospects.
 

Hobnobs

Pinko
Nov 29, 2011
9,281
2,648
Missing the two best Michigan born players?

Haven't watched a Wings game since the Jets beat them, so I'm not qualified to comment on them. Defense seems like it could use a Sergachev in the top 3. Maybe that's in the future?

Husso was a curious signing. One good year really. When does the Cossa era arrive?

Are Copp and Compher good enough top 6 players to propel the Wings into a playoff spot? Seems like if or when the young guys push them down to 3rd line players the Wings will be competitive again.

Copp is and isn't and that's why he sometimes play in the top-6. Although I wouldmn't say we have a top-6 more like a top-5 (Larkin, DeBrincat, Raymond, Compher and Kane). Then we have Kasper, Berggren, Copp and Tarasenko competing for the last top-6 spot.

Copp does have 5 goals which is on par with a decent 2nd line center.

Cossa is progressing well in the A and should probably get a cup of coffee in the bigs this season.

Defense core is for now Seider and Edvinsson with hopefully ASP coming in to round out the top-3 and then one or more of Buium/Wallinder/Johansson rounding out the bottom-6.

When it comes to defense core and prospects. I'm not too worried. As there is also Viro, Tuomisto, Cleveland, Anton Johansson and Keenan as possible bottom-4 defensemen.
 

wingerdinger

Registered User
Oct 21, 2018
1,290
1,275
Short term I hate how this team is constructed.

Slow small statured forward group. That have a considerable skill gap to most teams they come up against on a nightly basis.

With the worse 2nd defense pairing in the league.


Long term, Im quietly excited by the make up of the team. From a pesky forward group with an underrated skill set. To a defense core that are smooth skating and with size to spair.

With two blue chip goalie prospect to boot.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Winger98

Winger98

Moderator
Feb 27, 2002
23,276
5,428
Cleveland
Let's face it, Yzerman lucked out on Kucherov.

if everyone was being honest there are massive amounts of luck involved with the majority of prospects. Teams try to minimize it as much as they can but, in the end, they are drafting kids and hoping a lot of things break right over the course of the next five years for them to become quality NHLers.
 

LEAFANFORLIFE23

Registered User
Jun 17, 2010
47,417
16,045
Can Yzerman get a bit of criticism yet or is he still infallible?

I've been saying for months, possibly even a year that Yzerman is a shit GM.

I think people are finally starting to see it.

And It's not changing anytime soon.

at bestDetroit is like a hamster running on a hamster wheel.

at worst they are like trying to push a boulder up a hill but the boulder keeps rolling back down to the bottom.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fatass

Dread Clawz

LAWSonic Boom
Nov 25, 2006
27,989
10,009
Pennsylvania
I think there's a bit of denial going on among wings fans. Checking their board they're still blaming Holland for the state of the team in 2024. It's been six years, this is fully Yzerman's team at this point.

Fact is rebuilds fail more often than not. I have a feeling they're going to need to rebuild the rebuild. The talent they have is going to be starting to decline as soon as they're ready to compete (Larkin, Debrincat). I know people will say have patience but I think it's actually the wings that lacked patience and tried to exit the rebuild early. Had they tanked the Bedard year instead of signing mediocre vets they almost assuredly have that elite offensive piece in one of Bedard, Fantilli, Carlsson, or Michkov.

At this point it seems like they're waiting ten years for players to develop that are dime a dozen anyway. They look like they might top out as a Nashville or Minnesota at best. And the old Minnesota, the new one is quite talented.

And yes I know the penguins are in for a long painful rebuild themselves.

Yeah, they did the Buffalo and rushed the rebuild.
 

Pavels Dog

Registered User
Feb 18, 2013
20,792
16,551
Sweden
Yeah, they did the Buffalo and rushed the rebuild.
People say this but it's kind of the opposite, which is why the casuals/outsiders are getting impatient and the knowledgeable fans who pay attention to prospects and big picture are less stressed.

Yzerman has refrained from splashy, big-name trades or UFA signings, in general. Prospects are given time in europe, juniors or AHL. While signing Chiarot, Holl, Copp and acquiring Petry may seem like "rebuild-ending moves" to some, in reality they are placeholders exactly because Yzerman doesn't want to rush the rebuild by promoting prospects who aren't ready or spending major futures to acquire short-term help.

How many playoff games has that led to?
Okay, so any and all improvement is meaningless unless you lose in the 1st round?
 

Dread Clawz

LAWSonic Boom
Nov 25, 2006
27,989
10,009
Pennsylvania
People say this but it's kind of the opposite, which is why the casuals/outsiders are getting impatient and the knowledgeable fans who pay attention to prospects and development are less stressed.

Yzerman has refrained from splashy, big-name trades or UFA signings, in general. Prospects are given time in europe, juniors or AHL. While signing Chiarot, Holl, Copp and acquiring Petry may seem like "rebuild-ending moves" to some, in reality they are placeholders exactly because Yzerman doesn't want to rush the rebuild by promoting prospects who aren't ready or spending major futures to acquire short-term help.

Yes, he is letting the prospects in the system simmer and mature, which is great. But the problem is none of the prospects currently in the system are Bedard, Fantili, Michkov, Celebrini etc. caliber elite blue chip prospects. Edvinsson will be fantastic I think but he isn't carrying you to a Cup. The mediocre trades and UFA signings ensured that the Wings stayed in no man's land and weren't bad enough to draft any top 2 picks.
 

WarriorofTime

Registered User
Jul 3, 2010
31,362
20,326
Edvinsson looking like a hit with the Number 6 pick certainly is a promising development for the Wings long-term outlook.

I think you can give Yzerman the credit for not whiffing on any top draft choices so far like they did before him with Rasmussen (who is meh) and Zadina (who is already back in Europe). The more middling and Bonus 1st round picks will be a TBD and go a long way to if the Wings have a real "window" or not. Then they haven't had any real homeruns emerge outside of the first round, but it's very possible time will look back and just say those weren't great years to be stockpiling draft picks and there is not going to be a deep slate of high impact players.

All goes to a point that rebuilds have a lot of luck involved and the cult of personality either positive or negative surrounding hockey executives is likely overblown.
 

Pavels Dog

Registered User
Feb 18, 2013
20,792
16,551
Sweden
Yes, he is letting the prospects in the system simmer and mature, which is great. But the problem is none of the prospects currently in the system are Bedard, Fantili, Michkov, Celebrini etc. caliber elite blue chip prospects. Edvinsson will be fantastic I think but he isn't carrying you to a Cup. The mediocre trades and UFA signings ensured that the Wings stayed in no man's land and weren't bad enough to draft any top 2 picks.
I agree, why didn't Yzerman just draft Bedard? Is he an idiot?
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad