DaveG
Noted Jerk
I don't remember either, but I think the face off benefit doesn't outweigh Staal's disastrous defensive deficiencies.
Anyways, the whole "plan" seemed to be to weather the storm. It was almost like they were resigned to defend the 6-on-5 like a penalty kill. They just weren't aggressive. I realize that sometimes the other team breaks into the zone and possesses the puck, but it seemed like the Canes had no intention of standing them up at the blue line (like they'd done so well on the other standard PKs).
Won't disagree with that. Weather the storm seems to be exactly what they were thinking. IIRC it was about 30 seconds left on that draw. You win the draw and get a clear that's about 6-10 seconds off and another 5-10 for Detroit to reorganize within the offensive zone if they get the puck back. During those 6-10 you can get Eric off the ice and possibly get a shot at a SHG if you can manage to keep possession once you clear. Just didn't work in that case. It was a gamble call either way Kirk did it: keep the line together for that draw and if Jordan's kicked you're boned. Or break it up and if you can't get the clear you're boned. Kobayashi Maru.