Confirmed with Link: Dave Nonis TML GM|Burke retained as Senior Advisor to board - III
- Thread starter Leaf Rocket
- Start date
-
Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
- Status
hotpaws
Registered User
- Nov 21, 2009
- 22,109
- 6,695
I'm with you on this .
I remember when he was first hired someone in the media ( i can't remember who ) said him and Wilson would have a chance to succeed here if they put there egos aside and made it about the team and not themselves . I thought it was an odd thing to say but after 4 years of Burke and Wilson it's easy to see what he meant .
Mess
Global Moderator
You didn't approve of the JFJ firing?
Yes, very much so and other Leaf GMs and coaches of the past as well, but this one trumps that one.
I'm a results oriented guy that strongly believes in accountability for the performance of the team resides squarely on the shoulders of the GM in charge.
JFJ teams coming out of the lockout missed the playoffs by 3 points combined over 2 seasons combined and was justly fired for his failures to meet company objectives. Burke's teams missed the playoffs by 12, 14, 8 & 12 points after his 4 season and posted a below < .500 record on average over the course of his time here with only Edmonton, Columbus and NYI finishing below Toronto with less wins/points over that time.
nuck
Registered User
- Aug 18, 2005
- 11,751
- 2,759
I think he ran the 05,06,07 drafts so Bourdon, Grabner, and White which aren't too exciting, but they weren't high picks, and that result is likely more on the Director of Scouting. The trading or attempted trades are more telling.
Mess
Global Moderator
I live in BC so unfortunately I was force feed enough of Burke's dog and pony show ego media antics to last a life time when he was Vancouver's GM.
Ulf and I use to battle and discuss this on other message boards before HF even existed yet, with fellow Canuck fans at that time.
He was the same in Toronto only much worse now as he didn't age graciously when it came to his brash, self centered, larger than life, pompous, arrogant, bombastic attitude that apparently rubbed Bell/Rogers the wrong way in a very short period of time.
His poor record as GM more than enough reason to be fired but Leaf Nation caught a break as apparently it was Burke's mouth that eventually sealed his own demise, as MLSE wanted to have a better corporate image representing them going forward..
Last edited:
leafers
Registered User
- Oct 2, 2006
- 1,291
- 335
Doesn't the current Leafs/Marlies have better and more promising young talent than JFJs teams ever had?
Aren't you the guy who preaches youth and playing the kids as well as patience?
Why only stare at numbers and results when you can look more indepth?
This franchise is only losing fans for the most part, and what happened today will only further accelerate that.
Especially after that CBC report.
Especially after that CBC report.
ULF_55
Moderator
When you trade picks and young assets for those "final pieces" at the deadline it comes with a cost.
The Leafs were a contender, and everyone wanted to go for it back then, although I think their goaltender covered up some deficiencies.
This franchise is only losing fans for the most part, and what happened today will only further accelerate that.
Especially after that CBC report.
That`s cool maybe we`ll be able to get tickets pizza and beer for 20 bucks. Keep on MLSE.
January 19th just can't come soon enough
However, once games start, what is over/under for # of games before "Lets go Blue Jays" chant start at ACC rink? I say 15.
However, once games start, what is over/under for # of games before "Lets go Blue Jays" chant start at ACC rink? I say 15.
topched
Registered User
January 19th just can't come soon enough
However, once games start, what is over/under for # of games before "Lets go Blue Jays" chant start at ACC rink? I say 15.
First time the leafs get down by 3 or more goals. You can bet they're gonna hear it.
Mess
Global Moderator
Former Leaf GM Pat Quinn the predecessor to JFJ was even worse when it came to youth as he loved his vets and often used picks and prospects to his own betterment as both GM and coach.
A good GM in order to keep his job has to balance on ice success in the present in order to buy himself time to allow his draft picks time to develop. Burke's failures as GM to ice a competitive team in the present despite all the Kessel, Phaneuf, Giguere, Komisarek, Beauchemin, Lupul, Versteeg, Connolly, Armstrong etc etc big money quick fix attempts for immediate success in the end one of the factors why his own impatience and prospect pool no longer became an issue.
Prospects in the systems are still suspects until proven otherwise, and they don't put $$ in corporate pockets with missed playoff games when their not contributing to the team by not playing on it.
January 19th just can't come soon enough
However, once games start, what is over/under for # of games before "Lets go Blue Jays" chant start at ACC rink? I say 15.
If the rumored deal for Lou goes through than I will take Training camp as the start of the chants.
topched
Registered User
I'm with you Mess with regards to the timing and the sentiment etc.
I'm not thrilled that Burke was fired, I guess to rephrase, I would have been ok if Burke was fired and replaced by someone with a brand new direction. For that reason I'm a little disgruntled about the move.
I guess more importantly the one silver lining I can see in this signing is that Burke is no longer a lame Duck GM. I really hope Nonis is given some leash and a few years on his contract. Surely the GM should feel pressure to make the playoffs immediately, but I don't want it to be "job-saving, careless-move making pressure"
Listening now. Sounds like the board just didn't like Burke's attitude. That plus a poor performance = Bye bye.
If the team was doing well, they would overlook his attitude. But that wasn't the case.
Former Leaf GM Pat Quinn missed the playoffs a grand total of ONCE in his 6 years with the team.
The concern among fans is not about board not liking Burke's attitude. Its mainly about CBC reporting that board members giving "hockey advice" to GM. If thats the case, there is definitely a reason to worry.
Leafidelity
Existentially Drifting
Kind of like a Prince hearing the King died, immediately stuffing the crown on him, and pushing him out to address the public.
Mess
Global Moderator
I can certainly appreciate that point of view and position.
I think the lockout, shortened season, new Ownership and other timing issues are all reasons why going forward in the same direction with Nonis makes sense on the surface for MLSE. He knows the players, their value, the team needs and has all the inside knowledge required to hit the ground running due to the timing of this event. There really shouldn't be much of a speed bump, learning, transition period for MLSE that can hurt them by this move as it was rumoured Nonis was doing a large part of the GM work already behind the scenes for Toronto..
With that said I also believe because of all that I think Nonis is fully aware there is no honeymoon reprieve long leash adjustment excuse period here and results are expected from Ownership in much shorter order than a brand new GM and direction. They didn't want a full reset " clearing the slate" backwards direction but a building upon what has painstakingly taken all this time until now without playoffs during the current rebuild. IMO
- Status
