JFJ was actually a great GM draft-wise .. His only real "bust" was Tlusty, but even he's panning out to be what he was projected now (2 way winger with 20 goal potential) .. He also drafted Rask who turned out pretty well
JFJ's problem was his FA signings and trades, because he was under pressure from ownership to 'win now' so he went ahead and made moves that he was hoping would put the Leafs over the hump .. Obviously those moves didn't work and the Leafs got left out of prospects/picks for the future
Had JFJ been given the option to rebuild and sell off the Muskoka 5 instead of trying to resign them I bet the Leafs would be an annual cup contender now .. Rather we were left with a barren farm system and an AHL roster playing at the NHL level.
.. Now with what's happened today my greatest fear, as is many fans on this board, is ownership making the same mistake by wanting to 'win now' and trying to place a GM in a position to make this team a contender when it has no business being one yet.
Much like you criticize Burke for finishing in the bottom for 2/3 seasons, you praise JFJ for all those prospects we see now .. Wait 2-3 more seasons and you'll be praising Burke for all those draft picks he brought in (through trades mostly) assuming those prospects aren't traded.
It'll be an endless cycle until we have an ownership group that is patient .. And we're almost there! So to remove Burke from his position when we're on the cusp of seeing his true work, where he gathered all these young quality prospects, is wrong. Sure his stopgaps failed miserably over the last few years but that doesn't mean he hasn't improved this team going forward.