This probably should be merged into the general thread but,
Pat Maroon was a ~17 point player that sucks at fighting.
Ryan Hartman was a ~20 point player that sucks at fighting.
There are all kinds of paths, I don't think any player can be very accurately described with a sentence like that. I do think it is likely that he believes in himself, he has always come across in media as a self confident player.
If he goes on a small heater in the second half to 25-30 points while playing the same type of game and asks for $2MM AAV do you keep him? How much more, or how much less fits your definition of reasonable 4th line salary?