Got credits last night after passing the 70 hour mark. Tried out a few of the different endings.
I really, really enjoyed this game.
Despite all the bugs, all the dishonesty, the disastrous development and launch, all the content that was advertised but never made it into the game (which all rightfully deserves heaps of criticism).... I loved the game at its heart. Great adventure in a horrifying but mesmerizing setting.
I went in with very low hype, as first person isn't really my thing. My hype level was even lower thanks to all that came out before launch, but especially during/after the launch disaster. I came out more than pleasantly surprised in that regard. In fact, I was a bit shocked at how much fun I was having....
Gameplay was jank, but also a lot of fun. I ran a quickhacking/pistols combo, with just enough in Cool to benefit from the pistol-headshot-from-stealth insane crits. Silenced revolver primary, smart pistol secondary. Ran a katana on backup, but by the end with legendary Ping, you can pretty much clear a room with just quickhacking and if anyone charges you, you can cripple them with hacks and pick 'em off at your leisure.
The content issue is very noticeable, however. There are a lot of things that feel like they should matter, but ultimately don't....and don't make a ton of sense.
The storyline was interesting, and the characters really stood out for the most part. The main story is relatively short, but the side quests that stem off of the main quest with the main characters are where the game tends to really shine.
Once some more patches and content drops, I will probably do another playthrough. Might switch up to play as female V next time. I ran with male V this time, but I didn't think the voice actor was particularly strong.
I'm hoping this game gets expansions with the quality of the Witcher III (reportedly....I still have to play them. Should probably reinstall Witcher III.....). There's a lot to expand upon here.
For now, though, work on polish for sure. They have a lot of ground to make up. DLC can and should wait.
And finally, as much as I personally enjoyed it and want to recommend it, it's a bit of a tough sell. There's a lot you have to tolerate to get at the meat of this game, as good as that meat may be in my opinion.
In 6-12 months once it's more polished and you can buy the "complete edition" or whatever, absolutely.