There's a very big difference between these examples you presented and Arizona - all of the ones you mentioned have downtown arenas. Meaning it's very easy to get to them, especially via transit!
I wonder why Ottawa, who's in the very same boat as Arizona was in Glendale, also had the same problems as people don't want to drive the however long drive it is to Kanata three days out of the week to watch hockey, even when the team is good. Arena location matters a hell of a lot! It's a large reason why the Sens are looking at Lebreton Flats to develop the next Sens stadium.
The rest of your post is the same old bullshit that basically boils down to 'Canadians believing that Arizona is a blight upon hockey mankind' but I found the quoted especially hilarious because it is *so* disingenuous a talking point.
well you are wrong on every point.
Down town Arenas? ok lets look at Toronto...yep Down town....How does that help the fans who drive in from Hamilton? Burlington? Missisauga? Kitchener ?shit i was living in Peterborough and Leafs ticket holders were everywhere that's a 1:35 commute. in winter.
Montreal? same story Saint Hyacinthe, Saint Jerome. they drive in.
I drive 1 1/2 hours across frozen canadian highway to and 1 1/2 hours back from my teams games....
shit you think every Boston fan lives "down town" or getting from Newark or Queens or Brighton Beach to MSG for a rags game is shorter or easier?
how about the people who watch a Leafs game in TO then in Ottawa, then over to detroit? all in one week.
Ottawa is a different story.
It doesn't work because it's in the heart of the TO/Montreal market. In a world where you are either a Leafs fan or a Habs fan..from birth to grave, for multiple generations....no one cared about Ottawa. kinda like the how the XFL and others have failed over the years even though the US is THE "football market".
The only time the barn is full is when Leafs or Habs play. full of Away fans.. but full. because it's a real market. fans who drive a lot farther than the Ottawa to Kanata commute to see the teams they really love by the way.
so poor ottawa was never going to win. but they at least had an owner who lasted decades and died owning the team... now he's gone? time to move that team too.
now lets talk about winning....Toronto hasn't won since befor I was born. and I'm over 50! lots a piss poor losing seasons, so i guess they must have zero fans, crappy TV zero merch sales.....what? THAT MUCH MONEY? a that many sellouts?
see To is a hockey Market. AZ is not.
as for the "rest of my post" you get that the NHL is basically funded by Canadians right? our TV deal is bigger, our corporate sponsors pay more, our butts in seats subsidize your team.
3 billion lost. go ahead tell me that's a lie.
tell me how , even though in a make or break year, you can't even sell out a 5000 seat arena but "it's a hockey market". and this time it's different....