We definitely earned the victory, but it's impossible to say what would have happened with another goaltender in net. Different body size, different positioning, different angling, different directioning of the rebound, are all things that could have been different with another goaltender, not just Mike Smith, in net.
Not trying to argue with you, but it's always bugged me when announcers say the goaltender had no chance. There's always a chance. However slim, there's always a chance. The goaltender isn't always to blame, but there's always an opportunity to be setup differently, or react differently, and make a huge save.
For all we know smith swallows up Girardi's shot and doesn't allow a rebound at all...
We definitely earned the victory with the way we responded after that brutal first period.