Kessel is probably the most misunderstood player in the league. Including on these boards, honestly. As a player, he's is too cerebral, it's really hard to understand what he brings without seeing him every day live.
Basically,
the guy is incredibly creative offensively, and also he never wastes effort. For some defensemen that's seen a strength (Ryan Suter, Nick Lidstrom, Sam Girard etc), but many of us get pissed off that he doesn't finish checks, never even enters let alone wins board battles etc. But, he's also a world class passer and we really don't have a single player on our team who's an elite NHL finisher from more than 5 feet from the crease (Garland is our best finisher honestly, but not even the same league as someone like Tarasenko or Laine etc imo). So, last year Kessel was like "f*** it I'll stop looking for a pass' so he put up some goals, he still has a world class release with an accurate shot so good enough for 30-ish goals or so over the course of a full season. But he's still a much better set up guy and on the right team he can still help an above average sniper get to 40-50 goals for the next 2-3 years.
I'm really clueless as to how he'll do with Tourigny.
I don't think this would work at all, honestly. Tourigny's preaching accountability / fresh starts, what happens when Kessel doesn't finish any of his checks along the boards in the defensive zone? This will happen (and I say this as the largest Kessel fan on here). If Tourigny is telling the truth about accountability, Kessel gets fourth line minutes within the first 5-10 games of next year, maybe he even gets healthy scratched during the preseason. Do I think this is wise? Not necessarily. But Tourigny seems like a guy to treat everyone the same, if that's the case you can't overlook Kessel's lack of physicality.
If we can get a top 15 pick in this draft for Kessel I'd probably do it.
This, 100%. Kessel's not part of our long term solution (too old), and next year we're a borderline playoff team if that. So, if we're able to get any kind of first for him, which is likely, I think we have to take it. No disrespect to Kessel at all from my side (some of you may disagree), but imo he's the wrong player for our team right now. Alternatively, might be worth holding onto him until next year's deadline for a potential higher return, but either way no way we should even consider re-signing him after his contract expires at the end of next season