All comparison with DeBrincat at his draft... looks sooo good right now, but Caufield looks even more dynamic than DeBrincat, that's fantastic to have a player like him in Montreal Canadiens... thanks god he is only 5"7 because 6"0 he should go top 3 in draft 2019 night.
I think Caufield will be better.
At first glance, they seem very comparable, but they are different scorers. Debrincat has benefited from playing with Patrick Kane, which was a great match because above all else, Debrincat has an incredible one-timer.
Go look at all his goals in his two 40+ goals seasons and the great majority of his goals are from one-timers on a Kane pass. A few breakaways, a few wristers.
While Caufield has Suzuki, the latter just isn't Kane and Cole creates more plays and scoring chances by himself than Debrincat does. Both are great at finding soft ice without the puck, but Cole relies far more on his stickhandling and puck control to find space by himself when he has the puck. He also relies far more on his wrister, which is slso better than AD.
I'm willing to bet Debrincat will have fewer goals and will not reach 40 now that he doesn't have Kane feeding him.