And roll 11 forwards night after night? Why?
Our third line really isn't a problem. None of our lines are much of a problem right now. We're the highest scoring team in the league (well, last time I checked--might have changed a bit by now), and that's despite our top-3 scorers last year all pacing for fewer points.
The idea that teams would focus shutdown lines on anybody but Kucherov or Stamkos just doesn't check out. Third lines don't open up coverage for top-six lines.
Verhaeghe in particular shouldn't go down, because he's not waiver exempt. With Joseph, it's not really about us--he's not hurting the team. It's more about whatever's best to get him rolling and get his development back on track. I don't doubt he'll yo-yo between leagues a bit.
Believe it or not teams can and do focus there defensive lines against the other teams top lines. We see it all the time and is the primary reason Kuch and Stammer are on separate lines. Its called spreading the offense thru the lines. It is a reason Coop trys to roll four lines and he is not the only coach to do this. Even while the top lines are not scoring like last year they are still doing ok but ok is not good enough for HF Fans. The third line has to be a threat to score and right now they just are not. Yanni and Johnson have both proven they can Joseph has been the boat anchor. In fact Yanni moving from a functioning 4th line that was playing really well early in the season has now killed two lines. Yes its Coop's decision to try and balance lines that's his job.
Now why has Verhaeghe not performed at the NHL level. a guy that has cooked long enough in the AHL is 24 years old yet has not transitioned his game from 82 points in the AHL to essentially nothing at the NHL level. He may be one of those who must be in the top 6 to excel which puts this team in a pickle. The best thing now would be to move him for his career and to help this team at his age he will be on the decline until a top 6 spot opens here. As for Joseph last year he was the new toy 13-13-26 with his speed he should be better than even that on the 3rd line. I am not expecting 20 goals or 40 points for him either I expect he could be at least as good as Killer was on the 3rd line putting up mid teens goals and 30+ points. Killers 2nd year he hit 40 points on that 3rd line and this was not a very good team then. Yet he has been the whipping boy here.
Both Joseph and Verhaeghe are adding little to nothing to this team and have added to the early struggles throw in VAsi's struggle and the bonehead shit Shattenkirk's game is and that's the difference in last season and this years campaign. We miss what Strallman brought he was reliable to play defense rather than a forward having to drop into coverage nearly every shift to cover for Shattenkirk. I am not against putting the D up into the play but damn Shattenkirk thinks he is a forward always has since his day in St Louis that is how he has played. And his career numbers do not support the way he plays, as much time as he spends on the attack you would think he would average 15 goals and 50 points a year yet in 12 years he has broken 40 points just 4 times now yes he has only completed 3 seasons with more than 70 games and two of those years were 40 point years. I am really surprised he has not been on the IR yet but think it is a matter of time the question then will be who slides in his spot Rutta has played well and may get a shot or will they bring in Foote who is now ready for his chance?
Now with all that negativity I still think this 7 game stretch that started with the Panthers game will put the team back in playoff contention. They are not going to win the presidents cup but after last year im not sure that's a good thing anyway. They need to be hitting stride in late Feb and make a run it is doable for sure.