You need guys like him, Mika and Panarin to provide that Vet presence. I expect this team to potentially start competing as early as next year. You are breaking up two guys who have mad chemistry and really are good character for the locker room. Panarin and Trouba did not want to come here to be in a rebuild every year. 1st year I am sure they expected this, but enough is enough, time to turn the corner and start competing next season.
Also, how do you know he will break down in 3 or 4 years or not be the same player. You really don't. This isn't a Callahan or Dubinsky type player we are talking about. Some people on HF just want to dump a guy when he is approaching 30 yo. If we get 5 more very good years of Kreider, it's a win. If he is a 3rd line guy by the end of his contract, that's fine.
Everyone is guaranteeing that guys like Kakko, Kravtsov and Miller are gonna be studs or big key players. There are no guarantees. Except if I took a crap in a box, then you'd have a guaranteed piece of ****. Kreider has proven what he can do, and don't see him slowing down for at least another 5 or so years. For someone like Kreider to slow down will put him at just above average speed, so yeah...