Your being intellectually dishonest, he was not in fact scratched, he did play. He came close, like someone who almost crashed a car, did you or did you not. Yes those details matter, that it almost happens matters, but it didnt happen at that is the factual result. As for this benching nonsense, he has not been benched or scratched. Has be maybe missed a few shifts because the coach wants his to pick it up, sure. Almost velvety NHLer has had a coach try and get them going at some point, so it means nothing.
The attempt to convince us with a flimsy argument that your narrative holds water, while calling out others is suspect. Perhaps we can deal in facts, like his production rate which is that of a solid second liner, that he is a good team mate, that he can score at the NHL level consistently.. does his game have warts, sure. I don’t see Wayne Gretzky’s name on the Selke Trophy but it doesn’t mean he isn’t the great one.