Tricky.
I absolutely loved KJ heading into his draft and thought it was a great pick for the Jackets. And, I haven't soured on the pick, but I am questioning if Johnson will ever reach ppg upside, let alone elite (which I consider 100+). The fact that he just settled on the level of contract he did tells me that the Jackets have concerns and questions about said upside.
Watching Johnson play quite a bit confuses matters even more. Because the "glimpses" are there. But there is a softness and fragility to his game that I think hurts him long-term. I can't quite specify it yet, but it's just a gut feeling when watching him play. Is he going to blossom a little bit later like Mittelstadt has? Or is he going to fizzle out like some other forwards who graced us with flashes of eye-popping brilliance only to bounce around a few stops before vanishing for good? Not sure about Johnson at this point, tbh... but the skill is undeniable.