jj cale
Registered User
Great post, I agree.I have absolutely zero problem with anyone thinking that Bedard will not be a generational player at the NHL level. He definitely has the least obvious path to becoming so out his comparables in Crosby and McDavid. But to definitively say his pre-NHL body of work is any less impressive than Sid and McD is either wrong or disingenuous. And to group him in with Lafreniere, Hughes and Eichel, etc. as a prospect is just plain negligent.
As someone who has watched every game he has played since he entered the WHL as a 15 year old (including international play) this is my take:
A LOT of his game will have to change to succeed at the NHL level. He will put up points from the start, but like McDavid there will be a huge difference from having big statistical seasons and leading his team to the playoffs and beyond.
Among my concerns:
Footspeed/first step - his skating is fine and his edges elite but in junior as a centre he relied on deep regroups below his own D so that he could get the puck at top gear and overwhelm his opponent. He is incredibly hard to stop when he has the puck in full flight but in the NHL it will be a lot harder to get the time and space to do so. Even though he dominated the WJC’s, I found him playing wing and getting the puck on the half wall at a standstill to really mute his rush offense unless he cheated.
Long shifts, decision making, etc. - playing for such a bad team in Regina and being relied on so heavily for offense really harboured some bad habits. 2 minute shifts, dangling as the last man back, and taking low percentage shots are just a few of things that he will be forced to change at the next level.
All that said, he literally always adapts and finds a way to deliver. And not just deliver but deliver in the biggest moments. Has there honestly ever been a prospect who has clutched up time and time again like Bedard has? Every single time. There are no certainties and a lot of reasons Bedard might not reach generation status when it’s all said and said and done but given what we’ve seen at this point would you really bet against him?
I sure as hell won’t be.
Having said that I think Even if Bedard turns out to be a Kane level player hawk fans should still be over the moon as IMO he was just a shade below Crosby and Ovechkin at his very best, He would do very well to have his kind of career in Chicago and those are pretty big shoes for him to fill on it's own before we even start thinking about generational status.
His rookie season is going to be a lot of fun to watch and discuss.
Last edited: