Value of: Brady Tkachuk

[tTheVeganWoofMate]

McAvoy and Debrusk?
Hypothetically is that enough?

 

[CanadienShark]

no there isn't

Yes there are.

 

[Scintillating10]

First, it ain't going to happen so no need to post about why.

In a couple other threads people have talked about wanting Brady but I haven't seen any concrete offers.

So let take the following unlikely hypothetical - Staios want to make a big splash and fast change to culture. So the captain is on the market.

Sens want a hockey trade with limited long term futures.

6'4" 230lbs of PPG goodness with a mean streak. Unicorn and thrown back hockey player.

So, "Who wants it?"

Matheson and Flames pick, offer from Habs?

 

[Colezuki]

Caufield, +Habs first for me roll out the biggest top 6 fwds in the league next year

Dach 6’5, Tkachuk 6’4, slaf 6’4,

 

[DatDude44]

The blues offer anything not named Thomas to bring home one of our own

 

[SensFactor]

delete this thread lol

 

[Buresflyingelbow]

I’d be willing to talk Pettersson if the contract situation isn’t resolved before the trade deadline. Obviously a offseason move due to to the year Canucks are having and Ottawa has to add another great piece or two.

 

[FriendlyGhost92]

When it has zero bearing on the substance, yeah, it is semantics.

Next.

Yes. It's absolutely irrelevant that you actually said "Every" as an absolute, multiple times, rather than "Most" like you claimed AFTER you realized a #1RHD isn't available every draft.

It's absolutely relevant. If it wasn't relevant you would've kept claiming a #1RHD was available every draft. Instead, you backpedaled and diverted to "Most drafts" after realizing you were 100% wrong. Try again.

 

[h2]

delete this thread lol

Yes please.

It's actually annoying that these random trolls keep bumping it to quote something from a week ago that's completely irrelevant to the topic.

 

[TS Quint]

Yes please.

It's actually annoying that these random trolls keep bumping it to quote something from a week ago that's completely irrelevant to the topic.

You are almost single handedly keeping this thread alive.

 

[Wondercarrot]

Name the player from your team who is both the least likely to be traded and also perhaps the all time favourite player for that franchise - now assume that player has some dominant unicorn attributes and is just entering his prime and has another 10 years.

Nobody is trading that guy.
You won’t offer what it would take and Ottawa wouldn’t trade him if you did.

 

[FriendlyGhost92]

You are almost single handedly keeping this thread alive.

He got real mad once he tried to lie about how he actually claimed it was just "Most" drafts and then got quoted for each post that he quite literally said "Every draft".

I think my favorite part was the explanation of how "Every and most are a matter of semantics. There's no difference."

 

[EquivalentStay]

Caufield, +Habs first for me roll out the biggest top 6 fwds in the league next year

Dach 6’5, Tkachuk 6’4, slaf 6’4,

This is actually a solid offer, i dont see them trading Brady, but this is real strong, Goal Caufield is a beast and that first could be high

 

[dirtydanglez]

Caufield, +Habs first for me roll out the biggest top 6 fwds in the league next year

Dach 6’5, Tkachuk 6’4, slaf 6’4,

there is one problem with that.

 

[Akrapovince]

Caufield, +Habs first for me roll out the biggest top 6 fwds in the league next year

Dach 6’5, Tkachuk 6’4, slaf 6’4,

Would be cool but Montreal doesn’t even consider this.

 

[wintersej]

Do they? Matthew Tkachuk coming off a 109 point season, FAR better than what Brady has done, got an aging Huberdeau and Weegar. At the time people also felt that Calgary was robbed, so it’s not like that was felt to be fair value.

What other scoring PWF have been traded and commanded high values? Crouse as a prospect was traded for a 2nd and a 3rd, so it’s not like he was valued super highly then. I can’t even think of other PWF that were traded. Just because something is rare doesn’t mean it’s automatically high value.


I apologize on behalf of wings fans for this post.

As a rental Lucic got 13th OA in a loaded draft (not LAs fault the Bruins blew the pick), a top young goalie (Jones) that the Bruins flipped for another first, and a high scoring D prospect in Collin Miller that didn’t really end up hitting, but was well regarded at the time.

McAvoy and Debrusk?
Hypothetically is that enough?

McAvoy has more value across the lead than Brady. You are in a very small minority in what you think of McAvoy.

 

[Agent Zuuuub]

They’ll trade Stützle before treading Brady. Not happening.

yea no.

without stutzle or sanderson there is no team, there is no rebuild. they are by far the two best players on the roster.

not to mentioned signed the longest on the best contracts.

 

[bleedgreen]

Necas, higher end prospect Scott Morrow and a first from the Canes. I’d absolutely negotiate from that. I think I wouldn’t swap out Jarvis for Necas, I would send KK and adjust picks/prospects accordingly. He is signed to a long term deal at a fair price. He’s a solid 3C playing a 2C role, but he’s good at that role right now.

Canes have a bunch of B level prospects I think would all be on the table. I’d probably do Nikishin in a much smaller package but I doubt the team would.

 

[HockeyWooot]

If he became available literally every team would hear out prices.

As others mentioned it's highly unlikely the Sens ever win that deal. It'd have to be an offer so absolutely over the top and too good to refuse.

 

[10Ducky10]

Ehlers and a 1st in 2024.

 

[bert]

Caufield, +Habs first for me roll out the biggest top 6 fwds in the league next year

Dach 6’5, Tkachuk 6’4, slaf 6’4,

Wouldn't ever consider this under any circumstance for Ottawa.

Only deal I'd consider I've read is the one for McAvoy

 

[pld459666]

Zibanejad... But only if Ottawa also throws in a second

(it's funny.... Laugh)

Rather have Mika.

 

[SlafCaufield]

lol so sens fans want to move him now?