Value of: Brady Tkachuk

[lucaseider]

Nah, I'm not playing any game.

Interesting you still won't say why you brought that comment up, or admit it was pointless.

 

[Korpse]

Let me rephrase it since it's hard to comprehend.

Despite Brady having a similar stat line through his first 5 season's nobody expects or has expected Brady to have a similar jump in production that Matthew had. I think it's reasonable to expect him to be around PPG over the upcoming seasons.

That of course is in response to your comment that Brady isn't his brother, something nobody has claimed. To be even more clear PPG does not mean 100 points in a season.

 

[Golden_Jet]

His uniqueness doesn’t automatically make him better. Seider is a physical 1D in the mold of Pronger, of which there are few in the modern NHL. This doesn’t mean he’s better than Adam Fox just because he’s more unique.

He’s nothing like Pronger lol.

Interesting you still won't say why you brought that comment up, or admit it was pointless.

Time to admit you were wrong.

 

[RedHawkDown]

He’s nothing like Pronger lol.


Time to admit you were wrong.

He’s the closest thing in the modern NHL. No player will ever be like Pronger again because the game has shifted heavily away from that style of play.

Regardless, it’s completely beside the point. Pronger himself was a unique player during his time as well. Doesn’t mean he was better than lidstrom.

 

[Silky Johnson]

His uniqueness doesn’t automatically make him better. Seider is a physical 1D in the mold of Pronger, of which there are few in the modern NHL. This doesn’t mean he’s better than Adam Fox just because he’s more unique.

Dylan Larkin is not the Adam Fox of forwards.

 

[Strangle]

I’d love to see the Tkachuk brothers together, but I have no idea what it would take or what Zito would be open to send.

Marner and nylander for both?

 

[RedHawkDown]

Dylan Larkin is not the Adam Fox of forwards.

Didn’t say he was. Brady Tkachuk is also not the Chris Pronger of forwards.

 

[cowboy82nd]

Marner and nylander for both?

Well since Matthew is very happy in south Florida and has a NMC, Marner and Nylander might be enough to get Brady.

 

[Menzinger]

It's a bit of a shame its not the late 90s when GMs still wheeled and dealed blockbuster trades, would be fun to see the brothers united. Will likely never happen though

 

[Strangle]

Well since Matthew is very happy in south Florida and has a NMC, Marner and Nylander might be enough to get Brady.

Everyone has a NMC, trades don’t happen like this in the NHL anymore anyways.

NMC and cap bullshit make the league effectively a ‘no trade league’

But, also, no thanks lmao Brady isn’t worth both Marner and nylander

It's a bit of a shame its not the late 90s when GMs still wheeled and dealed blockbuster trades, would be fun to see the brothers united. Will likely never happen though

I agree, and I think it’s totally the leagues fault. They need to make some changes to the cap and contracts, etc to open up the avenues for trades again

 

[Laus723]

Marner and nylander for both?

Both what?

 

[Golden_Jet]

Didn’t say he was. Brady Tkachuk is also not the Chris Pronger of forwards.

He’s closer than Seider,
Pronger would also not be able to do what he did then, now.

 

[BradyTkachucky]

Big game from the captain

 

[Bankerguy]

Kuzmenko
Willander
Raty

You get a stud winger, 39 goals last year, rough start to this year but potted two tonight.
Blue-chip RHS top pairing potential Dman.
B-Tier Center prospect who's paying his dues in the AHL. Good progression season for him this year.

 

[Lukin1978]

Huberdeau and Weegar

 

[Silky Johnson]

View attachment 789720
Big game from the captain

My theory is that BT lurks on here and took exception to people saying he isn't a PPG guy.

24 in 29 with 42 goal pace. Considering the team disfunction that's pretty good. If the Sens get back on track he breaks 80p 40g

Huberdeau and Weegar

Gross.

Add a first and we still wouldn't take them for future considerations.

 

[TeamRenzo]

LOL, some people put a lot of effort into internet debates

 

[sennysensen]

Zero chance Tkachuk is traded. He's a unique player, and is their leader, and has term on his contract. New ownership / management looks patient, just took over and won't panic, that would be stupid.

Of course, other fans would love to get their hands on a Tkachuk.

Ottawa might mix it up by trading a player or 2 from their young core, but no way Brady is traded.

Tkachuk, Stutzle, and Sanderson are untouchables.

 

[hockey20000]

nothing I would never trade him tell hes post 30-32 lol

 

[CanadienShark]

Common enough that you can literally draft one every single year like I said. The same cannot be said for a top line power forward. I don't think you can really debate this.

For the comparison, I don't think in hindsight it was a good get for Nashville, but I was using it more for the value side of things. I think Jones and Seider have similar value at the time. I think Tkachuk has more value than Johansen at the time, there was no adding that took place.

There are top line powerforwards every draft dude.

 

[Edgelord]

hate the salary cap!!!!!!!!
if no cap we could have both Tkachuk brothers

 

[CanadienShark]

Do they? Matthew Tkachuk coming off a 109 point season, FAR better than what Brady has done, got an aging Huberdeau and Weegar. At the time people also felt that Calgary was robbed, so it’s not like that was felt to be fair value.

What other scoring PWF have been traded and commanded high values? Crouse as a prospect was traded for a 2nd and a 3rd, so it’s not like he was valued super highly then. I can’t even think of other PWF that were traded. Just because something is rare doesn’t mean it’s automatically high value.


I apologize on behalf of wings fans for this post.

Alex Tuch? Timo Meier?

 

[dirtydanglez]

trading him would be a mistake. should be the no.2/no.3 least movable player on the team. keep stutzle, sanderson, and tkachuk, everyone else is negotiable.

 

[h2]

There are top line powerforwards every draft dude.

no there isn't

 

[KirkAlbuquerque]

They’ll trade Stützle before treading Brady. Not happening.