Brady Tkachuk vs Mitch Marner

Who would you take on your team?

  • Brady Tkachuk

    Votes: 115 69.7%
  • Mitch Marner

    Votes: 50 30.3%

  • Total voters
    165

Golden_Jet

Registered User
Sep 21, 2005
26,072
13,468
xGA/60
View attachment 926234

ixG/60 : Tkachuk 3rd with 1.38, Marner 314th with 0.63

Brady Tkachuk has underperformed his expected goals metrics every single year.
Marner has outperformed his every single year.

Also marner is at 0.84 goals/60 EV since 22-23???
View attachment 926239

Again, your numbers simply appear to be WRONG.
5 on 5
Under new coach Brady has better xGA/60,
Team wise good for sixth in the league today.

24/25


23/24 until today

22/23 until today
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Xspyrit

Xspyrit

DJ Dorion
Jun 29, 2008
31,635
10,549
Montreal, Canada

You're set up on 5v5 :rolleyes:

ixG/60 : Tkachuk 3rd with 1.38, Marner 314th with 0.63

Brady Tkachuk has underperformed his expected goals metrics every single year.
Marner has outperformed his every single year.

Is it supposed to be a negative? Tkachuk's game is exhausting for opposing D-men and goalies

He is a volume shooter/everything. He keeps coming at you until it goes in.

Also marner is at 0.84 goals/60 EV since 22-23???
View attachment 926239

Again, your numbers simply appear to be WRONG.

My numbers come from Natural Stat Trick. I don't know where you're taking this but it's not even on the same filters as in your first table... lol
 

dgibb10

Registered User
Feb 29, 2024
3,425
2,977
You're set up on 5v5 :rolleyes:



Is it supposed to be a negative? Tkachuk's game is exhausting for opposing D-men and goalies

He is a volume shooter/everything. He keeps coming at you until it goes in.



My numbers come from Natural Stat Trick. I don't know where you're taking this but it's not even on the same filters as in your first table... lol
Screenshot 2024-11-04 at 9.09.12 PM.png


A) I'd recommend using evolving hockey
B) if you are using NST, use 5v5. NST includes empty net situations in their EV numbers

Which in this case is what is skewing the totals massively.
 

Bileur

Registered User
Jun 15, 2004
18,778
7,638
Ottawa
You're set up on 5v5 :rolleyes:



Is it supposed to be a negative? Tkachuk's game is exhausting for opposing D-men and goalies

He is a volume shooter/everything. He keeps coming at you until it goes in.



My numbers come from Natural Stat Trick. I don't know where you're taking this but it's not even on the same filters as in your first table... lol

Case in point

 
Last edited:

Positive Vibes

Habs4Life
Jun 24, 2016
1,223
487
Canada
I think you bumping an almost month old joke in a thread about Tkachuk supports his point about relative fan base insecurity.
yet i just came in here now to check the thread out?
insecure might have been the most ironic thing you could have said when considering what the other poster commented lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: SlafySZN

Bileur

Registered User
Jun 15, 2004
18,778
7,638
Ottawa
yet i just came in here now to check the thread out?
insecure might have been the most ironic thing you could have said when considering what the other poster commented lol

Not sure how coming in here to check a thread out changes the fact you jumped at a weeks old quip to defend a perceived slight.

Not exactly a behaviour that screams self assurance.
 

Positive Vibes

Habs4Life
Jun 24, 2016
1,223
487
Canada
Not sure how coming in here to check a thread out changes the fact you jumped at a weeks old quip to defend a perceived slight.

Not exactly a behaviour that screams self assurance.
i dont think your reading what im saying or just can't understand it for some reason
again go read the other guys posts to understand why you saying im acting 'insecure' is very ironic

bringing up a guy that isn't being discussed in the thread is insecure because a fan of another team commented on a post is the definition of insecurity. again the irony your post yet again is very ironic.

also theres no timeline on commenting on another posters comment unless theres a rule about it?
 
Last edited:

jbeck5

Registered User
Jan 26, 2009
16,787
3,647
i dont think your reading what im saying or just can't understand it for some reason
again go read the other guys posts to understand why you saying im acting 'insecure' is very ironic

bringing up a guy that isn't being discussed in the thread is insecure because a fan of another team commented on a post is the definition of insecurity. again the irony your post yet again is very ironic.

also theres no timeline on commenting on another posters comment unless theres a rule about it?

You're both insecure.

I don't go into habs threads to argue with Habs fans. Heck, I don't mind saying my team sucks...I do it often.

You should try that. Then you would really be not insecure.

Prove your lack of insecurity by not going to other teams boards or even talking about other teams...then repeatedly talk about how your own team sucks.

No one will call you insecure anymore lol
 

Positive Vibes

Habs4Life
Jun 24, 2016
1,223
487
Canada
You're both insecure.

I don't go into habs threads to argue with Habs fans. Heck, I don't mind saying my team sucks...I do it often.

You should try that. Then you would really be not insecure.

Prove your lack of insecurity by not going to other teams boards or even talking about other teams...then repeatedly talk about how your own team sucks.

No one will call you insecure anymore lol
this isn't the sens board.
sens fan brought up another team that wasnt being discussed not me? lol

Zero f***s given from this Sens fan.
i totally believe that.
 

jbeck5

Registered User
Jan 26, 2009
16,787
3,647
this isn't the sens board.
sens fan brought up another team that wasnt being discussed not me? lol


i totally believe that.

Until you learn to make fun of your team and be able to praise your rivals like I do, you'll be called insecure by others... especially if your team isn't world beaters like none of our teams are.

Also, does anyone know how to check your own post history? I'll show you me shutting down other sens fans who were making fun of the Habs by praising them and then shitting on the sens.

I wonder if you've ever done something like that? It would be a start.
 

NyQuil

Big F$&*in Q
Jan 5, 2005
99,087
65,380
Ottawa, ON
Until you learn to make fun of your team and be able to praise your rivals like I do, you'll be called insecure by others... especially if your team isn't world beaters like none of our teams are.

Also, does anyone know how to check your own post history? I'll show you me shutting down other sens fans who were making fun of the Habs by praising them and then shitting on the sens.

I wonder if you've ever done something like that? It would be a start.

What’s dumb is that I’ve done nothing but praise Hutson. You can check my post history.

My post was a joke aimed at a specific poster much earlier in the thread, and this guy can’t let it go.

Some people are just easily triggered.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jbeck5

jbeck5

Registered User
Jan 26, 2009
16,787
3,647
What’s dumb is that I’ve done nothing but praise Hutson. You can check my post history.

My post was a joke aimed at a specific poster much earlier in the thread, and this guy can’t let it go.

Some people are just easily triggered.

He's biased. He doesn't know how to make fun of his team or praise his rivals.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad