Well do you we want to chase 8th for the next few seasons until Phaneuf's decline, or did we want to grow into something better with more cap flexibility after the Greening, Michalek, Cowen deals ran out? I don't think Phaneuf is going to magically turn this team into something better. Maybe some improvement, but certainly not a contender.
What was the ONE thing this fanbase has been harping on the team to acquire to move them away from the constant mediocrity of finishing between 7th and 9th?!?
A LEGIT 2nd pairing defenceman.
Guess what, Murray went out and got one. And in the process, dumped two awful contracts that were always pointed to as huge negatives of his tenure as GM.
What the **** were we going to spend that cap space on if we let Greening and Cowen's contracts pass?!? Ottawa is NOT a free agent destination. There wasn't going to be a line-up of guys wanting to play in a small market.
Does this make us a contender? Maybe, maybe not. But even in the short term, this does wonders for our defence because it alleviates the pressures on guys like Ceci and it moves Weircoch down into a servicable 5-6 pairing with Boro. That alone improves our defence ten fold and actually does make us more of a legitimate hockey team.