Value of: Best offer for Scheifele

[Heldig]

Erik Brannstrom + Collin white + 1st (lottery protected) + 3rd

Oof.

Take out Brannstrom and White, add Pinto and remove the lottery protection on the 2022 1st. THAT would be worth trading a ppg #1 C (5 years in a row despite his very real struggles so far this year).

 

[Tripledeke333]

I'd offer Cole Caulfield.

Has may also have to send a roster play to balance salary.

 

[GreatSaveEssensa]

I'd offer Cole Caulfield.

Has may also have to send a roster play to balance salary.

We would consider Suzuki as well as Cole. But would really have to think long and hard about that

 

[Hunter368]

We would consider Suzuki as well as Cole. But would really have to think long and hard about that

Habs can’t trade Suzuki, he’s their golden goose. CC is a smaller right winger, not a huge need (maybe replace Wheeler once he retires/traded) and he’s struggled this year. Trading a 1C for CC+ would not be a good idea. Only way I would even remotely consider that personally is if no young C prospect was offered by all other teams (which is unlikely, teams in need would offer a C prospect++) plus Copp & PLD extended giving the Jets a 1C & 2C signed. A 1C PPG in his prime signed at 6.125 million for 2.5 years holds huge value.

 

[GreatSaveEssensa]

Habs can’t trade Suzuki, he’s their golden goose. CC is a smaller right winger, not a huge need (maybe replace Wheeler once he retires/traded) and he’s struggled this year. Trading a 1C for CC+ would not be a good idea. Only way I would even remotely consider that personally is if no young C prospect was offered by all other teams (which is unlikely, teams in need would offer a C prospect++) plus Copp & PLD extended giving the Jets a 1C & 2C signed. A 1C PPG in his prime signed at 6.125 million for 2.5 years holds huge value.

There is no situation in this world where I would consider trading Scheifele with the main piece coming back being Caufield. It would start with Suzuki and depending on what else the Habs added would be decided from that.

 

[CanadienShark]

There is no situation in this world where I would consider trading Scheifele with the main piece coming back being Caufield. It would start with Suzuki and depending on what else the Habs added would be decided from that.

That just won't happen though. Habs aren't trading Suzuki. If that means no Scheifele, so be it. If there's no workable deal around Caufield, Guhle, etc. then there's no deal to be had. Dvorak can be included if need be, but I assume the Jets would just run Copp at #2C assuming he's re-signed.

 

[Ciao]

There's been more than 50 replies.

Has anyone offered a player that is even remotely as good as Scheifele in return?

I didn't think so.

That's what happens when you go shopping just because you're pissed off.

 

[Hunter368]

There is no situation in this world where I would consider trading Scheifele with the main piece coming back being Caufield. It would start with Suzuki and depending on what else the Habs added would be decided from that.

Problem with that outside Suzuki which they wouldn’t trade, CC is really the only prospect I would even have mild interest in from the Habs. So I don’t think Habs could put together an offer I personally would be interested in (Romanov maybe interesting also, but he hasn’t had a great year either). I’m not saying their other prospects are crap, they just have nothing we don’t already have in prospects. So if we signed Copp & PLD our top 6 is taken care of at centre position……what can the Habs offer to add to CC that fills any Jets needs that the Jets would consider trading a 1C PPG in his prime signed to a incredible contract at 6.125 per year for 2.5 years.

I can’t see the Habs trading for Mark if they’re rebuilding, which is yet to be determined. If they don’t rebuild then maybe.

 

[GreatSaveEssensa]

There's been more than 50 replies.

Has anyone offered a player that is even remotely as good as Scheifele in return?

I didn't think so.

That's what happens when you go shopping just because you're pissed off.

Haha. I get the impression you think I feel this is real life or something?

Its a hockey forum that discusses hypothetical situations conjured up in the minds of armchair wannbe GM’s. Its for shits and giggles. I dont get offended nor do I take anything as fact. Lets just chill out and enjoy the chatter as we would if we we’re sitting in a pub with a few beers in front of us and the game on in the background

 

[SensEnforcer]

Oof.

Take out Brannstrom and White, add Pinto and remove the lottery protection on the 2022 1st. THAT would be worth trading a ppg #1 C (5 years in a row despite his very real struggles so far this year).

I counter with Pinto/C.Brown/Boucher/1st protected

Blue chip prospect/Top 6 proven nhler/ 2021 top ten draftee / A most likely top 10 1st

 

[Heldig]

I counter with Pinto/C.Brown/Boucher/1st protected

Blue chip prospect/Top 6 proven nhler/ 2021 top ten draftee / A most likely top 10 1st

Darn good counter offer. I know very little about Boucher other than he was an off the board pick. What are the conditions on the 1st?

 

[Gnome17]

Boston offers Jake Debrusk, he is really good (Better than Thomas Chabot, Kyle Connor and Matthew Barzal just to name a few).

 

[bernmeister]

To rangers for 1st, laf, Schneider, kravtzov

no

would not overpay that package for PLD let alone Scheif

rangers are not doing age for youth

also next yr we have zero cap for anybody
and it will stay that way until Trouba is moved

 

[Gabe Kupari]

Girard, Newhook, +

MacKinnon and Scheifele down the middle would be insane. But I seriously doubt Winnipeg has any desire to trade him.

Byram Newhook

 

[Gabe Kupari]

Rangers? Laf and Schneider plus 1st?

 

[Lindberg Cheese]

Rangers? Laf and Schneider plus 1st?

Can we add Fox to balance this out?

 

[Gabe Kupari]

Can we add Fox to balance this out?

Laf and Schneider definitely not as good as 1c Scheif so not sure why

 

[SensEnforcer]

Darn good counter offer. I know very little about Boucher other than he was an off the board pick. What are the conditions on the 1st?

Always lottery protected defer to the next year until its not

so it will be a 2030 pick

 

[Royale With Cheese]

Scheifele is the most talented player on the Winnipeg Jets. He has incredible offensive skill.

He’s definitely not himself, we can see that, but I would not move him for anything other than another 1C.

He needs a new head coach.

 

[Peter Griffin]

Something involving Pettersson.

 

[GaryPoppins]

He’s had Covid for the last 2 and a half seasons? If he is still recovering why is Maurice playing him 22 minutes a night with other/better options?

This guy gets it

 

[GaryPoppins]

Points are not every thing. You should check out his give a shit meter on defence.

I’d say in general.. he just seems to not care

 

[Rebels57]

If he was European, he'd get killed by media for his defensive play.

 

[GreatSaveEssensa]

I’d say in general.. he just seems to not care

It really is a shame. After that playoff run in 2018 I thought he was going to be one of the top centres in the league for us for many years to come. I just really dont understand what the hell happened to him along the way.

 

[GreatSaveEssensa]

If he was European, he'd get killed by media for his defensive play.

Go to the Jets board and check it out. Trust me when I say that he does get killed by the fans for it. If he was playing in a major market he would be getting killed by the media as well, nationality aside