Toggle sidebar

Auston Matthews Discussion Thread

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Now that’s a bend...

171CF438-8EE1-460E-82FB-2A76C2565ECB.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Volcanologist, BrannigansLaw, authentic and 4 others
Stephen said:
My very uneducated, no inside sources guess is Matthews could miss a couple of games based on the way Andersen's "day to day" seems to be stretching into a week to week. But let's hope for the best.
Click to expand...

As I had guessed, this day to day thing could be stretching out to a week minimum.

Don't like the cut of Andersson's jib. Dirty player:

 
Stephen said:
As I had guessed, this day to day thing could be stretching out to a week minimum.

Don't like the cut of Andersson's jib. Dirty player:

Click to expand...

That whole team is so unlikeable, I'm glad they're stuck in mediocrity
 
Teeder Keon said:
When I see that , I have more respect for player of past eras that were skilled scorers , Bossy and the Flower and so many others with their tree limb sticks and old school equipment and training ...
Click to expand...
Bossy and flower those guys using the warped blade? Makes me appreciate the skill of the old players with the flat blade, Like Teeder, Apps and Conacher... ;). Just funnin with ya old timer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Teeder Keon
Confucius said:
Bossy and flower those guys using the warped blade? Makes me appreciate the skill of the old players with the flat blade, Like Teeder, Apps and Conacher... ;). Just funnin with ya old timer.
Click to expand...
I know brotha , I know , but even in the 60s and 70s the sticks and equipment and nutrition and workout regiments and everything else that these athletes get now ( rightfully and wonderfully so ) there’s a appreciation for them and like you say going even further back to your examples , and that’s not even talking about the goalies ... unbelievable man , unbefrikenevable !
But today’s athletes and hockey players , wow they are incredible no question about it , but I still liked the hockey better at a slower more ball / street hockey speed that we kinda felt , hey we can do that !
But we certainly can’t say that now
No way I could ever do what these guys and girls do now.
And how special was it like to save up money to go out and get a beautiful wooden stick once a year if you where lucky , to go into a store and look at all those wooden sticks and pick one out ....to play on the street and show your buddies your new stick ahhhhhh now that was hockey day and night and week in Canada ...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ER89 and Confucius
Teeder Keon said:
I know brotha , I know , but even in the 60s and 70s the sticks and equipment and nutrition and workout regiments and everything else that these athletes get now ( rightfully and wonderfully so ) there’s a appreciation for them and like you say going even further back to your examples , and that’s not even talking about the goalies ... unbelievable man , unbefrikenevable !
But today’s athletes and hockey players , wow they are incredible no question about it , but I still liked the hockey better at a slower more ball / street hockey speed that we kinda felt , hey we can do that !
But we certainly can’t say that now
No way I could ever do what these guys and girls do now.
And his special was it like to save up money to go out and get a beautiful wooden stick once a year if you where lucky , to go into a store and look at all those wooden sticks and pick one out ....to play on the street and show your buddies your new stick ahhhhhh now that was hockey day and night and week in Canada ...
Click to expand...
Funny I remember playing ball hockey with a new stick and trying to not let the stick touch the pavement. lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: ER89 and Teeder Keon
Teeder Keon said:
When I see that , I have more respect for player of past eras that were skilled scorers , Bossy and the Flower and so many others with their tree limb sticks and old school equipment and training ...
Click to expand...

The size of goaltending equipment (and the goalies themselves) balances out that stick advantage though.
 
BlueForever75 said:
Matthews still scores as much if not more with a wooden stick if goalies had equipment that wasnt oversized. Who you kidding.
Click to expand...
Yes, but does he get to wear 15lb shoulder pads after they get soaking wet?
And is he wearing 5lb skates that flop about the ankles as well?
Does he get to play-act a ski-surfing scene where he gets to play the power boat while one or two defensemen hook onto him like the ski-surfers?


We can't have half measures here.

I believe he would be among the best if we were transported into those eras and forced into the same rules and equipment, but I'm still unconvinced he would stand out like a Wayne or Mario. It's why those 2 especially, are just so mesmerizing.
 
pcruz said:
Yes, but does he get to wear 15lb shoulder pads after they get soaking wet?
And is he wearing 5lb skates that flop about the ankles as well?
Does he get to play-act a ski-surfing scene where he gets to play the power boat while one or two defensemen hook onto him like the ski-surfers?


We can't have half measures here.

I believe he would be among the best if we were transported into those eras and forced into the same rules and equipment, but I'm still unconvinced he would stand out like a Wayne or Mario. It's why those 2 especially, are just so mesmerizing.
Click to expand...

I would disagree with you on the assessment. But we are entitled to our own opinions.

If Sid or Connor played in the Gretzky or Lemieux era they would be as good if not better when you factor in Sid and Connor's skating ability compared to the other two. If Ovechkin played in that era he would be the all time goals leader not Gretzky. How many goals did Gretzky score on a slapper from top of the circle coming down the wing? Now put Ovechkin or Matthews in that era with their shots!!!

Equipment aside its how the game is played today versus the past. Gretzky wasnt touched at all. If he was, the opponent was punished. When you have the ability to skate freely like Gretzky did, of course the points and goals will rack up.

Do not get me wrong, I still believe Gretzky is the best of all time and I was privileged to watch him and see him play. But had the players of today played in those eras, it would be interesting to see what stats they would be putting up. Much more is expected today of superstars then yesteryears. Gretzky's defensive game was below average, if Matthews or Crosby or MacKinnon or McDavid played defense like Gretzky today, they would be benched.

Its a different game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Confucius
pcruz said:
Yes, but does he get to wear 15lb shoulder pads after they get soaking wet?
And is he wearing 5lb skates that flop about the ankles as well?
Does he get to play-act a ski-surfing scene where he gets to play the power boat while one or two defensemen hook onto him like the ski-surfers?


We can't have half measures here.

I believe he would be among the best if we were transported into those eras and forced into the same rules and equipment, but I'm still unconvinced he would stand out like a Wayne or Mario. It's why those 2 especially, are just so mesmerizing.
Click to expand...

It's fair to say he would score a lot more in the seasons where every player scored a lot more. Most likely he would not be scoring close to 200 points if he grew up in the 60s and 70s, but around 70 goals would seem within reach.
 
BlueForever75 said:
I would disagree with you on the assessment. But we are entitled to our own opinions.

If Sid or Connor played in the Gretzky or Lemieux era they would be as good if not better when you factor in Sid and Connor's skating ability compared to the other two. If Ovechkin played in that era he would be the all time goals leader not Gretzky. How many goals did Gretzky score on a slapper from top of the circle coming down the wing? Now put Ovechkin or Matthews in that era with their shots!!!

Equipment aside its how the game is played today versus the past. Gretzky wasnt touched at all. If he was, the opponent was punished. When you have the ability to skate freely like Gretzky did, of course the points and goals will rack up.

Do not get me wrong, I still believe Gretzky is the best of all time and I was privileged to watch him and see him play. But had the players of today played in those eras, it would be interesting to see what stats they would be putting up. Much more is expected today of superstars then yesteryears. Gretzky's defensive game was below average, if Matthews or Crosby or MacKinnon or McDavid played defense like Gretzky today, they would be benched.

Its a different game.
Click to expand...

I believe if Crosby or McDavid, or Matthews for that matter went back in time to the 1980s NHL, especially the early 80s, it goes without saying they would be by far the best players. Their overall skill level would simply be too much to contend with, even using the older equipment. If they were born back then though I really wonder how they would've done, although they would be very different players than they currently are. Cross era comparisons are not fair either way you look at them but they're fun to think about.
 
authentic said:
I believe if Crosby or McDavid, or Matthews for that matter went back in time to the 1980s NHL, especially the early 80s, it goes without saying they would be by far the best players. Their overall skill level would simply be too much to contend with, even with the relative disadvantage of using the older equipment. If they were born back then though I really wonder how they would've done, although they would be very different players than they currently are. Cross era comparisons are not fair either way you look at them but they're fun to think about.
Click to expand...

Your right. Their skills would have been developed differently so you never know. One thing though equipment and skillsets aside. If superstars of yesteryears and todays were allowed to skate and play the game to their strengths, what would their stats be?

We understand that playing styles and equipment will evolve. But not being touched and being allowed to play the game. Being protected. What would the stats read? Thats the question.
 
BlueForever75 said:
Your right. Their skills would have been developed differently so you never know. One thing though equipment and skillsets aside. If superstars of yesteryears and todays were allowed to skate and play the game to their strengths, what would their stats be?

We understand that playing styles and equipment will evolve. But not being touched and being allowed to play the game. Being protected. What would the stats read? Thats the question.
Click to expand...
Well for starters Mathews would get a penalty for playing with that broken stick. LOL! There is that.

Yeah the players are always getting better. Every now and then you get players ahead of their time but as the years go by they get passed. Athletes are always getting faster, stronger.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Teeder Keon
Critical13 said:
Have you seen the goalies they were shooting on? :D
Click to expand...


If you haven’t , watch this tiny clip for a tiny bit of respect for not only Mr Bower but all goalies in that era and earlier
Also in case you weren’t aware ... Mr Glen Hall with over 500 plus games in a row without missing a game without a mask mostly
Go Leafs Go
 
  • Like
Reactions: Confucius
Teeder Keon said:


If you haven’t , watch this tiny clip for a tiny bit of respect for not only Mr Bower but all goalies in that era and earlier
Also in case you weren’t aware ... Mr Glen Hall with over 500 plus games in a row without missing a game without a mask mostly
Go Leafs Go
Click to expand...


Teeder...I LOVE hockey history and have the upmost respect for these men. I was just pointing out that the arms race on both sides make those sticks a requirement. If shooters couldn't get that extra velocity, we'd be watching 1 or 2 goal games most nights. Instead, we get 4 or 5.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Teeder Keon
Critical13 said:
Teeder...I LOVE hockey history and have the upmost respect for these men. I was just pointing out that the arms race on both sides make those sticks a requirement. If shooters couldn't get that extra velocity, we'd be watching 1 or 2 goal games most nights. Instead, we get 4 or 5.
Click to expand...
I hold no Negative words for today’s hockey or the incredible athletes and players and the evolution of it or any sport .. I marvel at all of it .. and am in awe of the breakneck speed and agility and ability of all these players , it truly is a treat to watch how they can do the things they do at the speed they can do it with ...
again!
Just keeping it real ...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Confucius
Teeder Keon said:


If you haven’t , watch this tiny clip for a tiny bit of respect for not only Mr Bower but all goalies in that era and earlier
Also in case you weren’t aware ... Mr Glen Hall with over 500 plus games in a row without missing a game without a mask mostly
Go Leafs Go
Click to expand...


Imagine getting a Bobby Hull slapshot to the face?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Teeder Keon
authentic said:
Imagine getting a Bobby Hull slapshot to the face?
Click to expand...
I’ve always been blown away with any goalie that played without a mask , but watching that clip and watching Mr Bower not only save the puck while on his side on the ice , but actually stretch his neck out as to literally stop the puck with his face , that is one of the most incredible things I’ve ever watched in hockey , bar none
 
  • Like
Reactions: Confucius, zeke and authentic
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom