Senators looking just as bad. I love Karlsson as a player but, honestly, how did he ever win an award for best defenseman? They really need an Art Ross for D.
Sens fans will say he has no help out there because Methot is the only other defenseman for Ottawa worth a damn, but Karlsson really isn't very good defensively on his own. I think his positioning isn't all that good and he can often make up for it with his skating, but not often enough. He has a quick stick and can steal pucks, but it isn't going to work every time, and gets caught up ice at times as well.
On the other hand he possesses the puck so well when he gets it on his stick and can start the rush the other way so well, that it balances out his obvious pure defensive deficiencies. A guy who's good along the boards, blocks shots, and stays in position but can't move the puck to save his life really ends up hurting you more defensively than the guy who can quickly transition to offense, even if he makes some defensive mistakes, because he spends so much less time playing defense.
All that said, I'm not advocating that it's enough to win the Norris...I think the Norris should be the best overall defenseman in the league that year, a guy who can play good defense against the leagues best players, move the puck well, and put up points.
Anyways, anyone else think that Craig Berube's Flyers are startign to look an awful lot like Peter Laviolette's Flyers? Crappy defense, crappy goaltending, lots of offense and hope they outscore the other team?