You suggested playing him with Stützle, in the top 6. I think he’d be an upgrade for Amadio on the 3rd line, but he doesn’t have the offensive capabilities to complement Stützle, so we’d still have the same issue as we do today. No one to play with Stützle.
Yes, sort of like a 3rd liner like Greig played on a top line this season, or Howden in Vegas, like Joseph did a bit in the past, etc. NHL teams more often than not build duos and then plug a lesser talented guy who could still help them out
Again, in my scenario,
the winger for Stutzle was Batherson...
But as I explained, problem is Batherson is ALSO needed on the other scoring line so we can't do that.
If we’re trading for another winger, it needs to be a guy who can put the puck in the net. Bonus if he brings speed.
Problem with your counter arguments is it forces me to explain a lot of parallel things. Players RARELY play on the same line all season. Top-6 forwards usually always play in the Top-6 but as soon as there is an injury or a hole in the top-6, a lot of the 3rd line caliber players will play games/shifts in that hole. Which is how guys like Greig, Joseph and Kakko (in that scenario) end up playing there.
I guess it should be clear now.
Even if we acquired Kakko (but would have had to get rid of Perron or Amadio), we would still need a Top-6 forward.
Kakko doesn’t score and is slow. And he’ll be a guy looking for 3.5M+ on his next deal and can walk himself to UFA.
Trading any of the limited assets we have for him to slightly upgrade on Amadio would’ve been dumb.
He scores well for the 3rd line, as already addressed. He has scored on average 15 goals per 82 games in the NHL, not that bad for a guy who has started at 18 y/o and is still only 23 y/o. That is usually not the most productive years for a NHL forward.
I'm not sure why you think he'd ask for that kind of raise? Doesn't fit with how you're valuing him.
Finally, regarding the assets, we don't have a Borgen but I would have easily paid a 3rd + 6th for a 23 y/o 2-way 3rd line forward.
And if you think this is dumb, then what is "
slightly upgrade on Amadio"? lolz Kakko is 5 years younger and has more career points than Amadio... who is not good at anything while Kakko is solid in several aspects.