“The system holds back this players offense” always brings back memories of Ranger fans thinking Gomez would score 100+ points for them.
The top guys get their points; most systems aren’t choking 10-20 points off their top offensive players.
Some people probably had a faulty premise when Scott Niedermayer got 60+ points with Anaheim coming out of the lockout while ignoring the sheer amount of PPs in those years.
I think the unseasoned chicken wing deduction was that Niedermayer was a 40 point D because he was being held back. Rather than that he was relegated to PP2 for a few years and the Devils were typically at the bottom of the league in PP chances.
1998-99: 46 points (24 ES, 21 PP, 1 SH)
--------- Rafalski arrives
1999-00: 38 points (29 ES, 9 PP)
2000-01: 35 points (24 ES, 11 PP) -- missed 20+ games due to holdout
2001-02: 33 points (23 ES, 10 PP)
2002-03: 39 points (29 ES, 10 PP) -- Nieds back on PP1 but #30 ranked PP unit
2003-04: 54 points (26 ES, 25 PP, 3 SH)
---------- PPs for everybody
2005-06: 63 points (25 ES, 36 PP, 2 SH)
2006-07: 69 points (35 ES, 34 PP)
By the time Gomez left in 2007, the refs would begin to put away the whistles.