We could have, for example, offered Kakko $4 million for 1 year. We would have been out a 2nd round pick, or NY would have been forced to pay him $4 million instead of $2 million. Maybe then they can't afford Trocheck. Meanwhile, if Kakko breaks out, NJ has him for three more years of team control, and if he doesn't, it's just a 2nd round pick. It makes a lot of sense for Kakko too, as it boosts his earnings much earlier in his career.
I just like to talk about it because it's fun, but it just doesn't ever happen. Kakko wasn't the only one I wanted. I also wanted to offer sheet Liljegren. It is (or at least should be) a great weapon against top heavy teams contract wise. We talked about several other players that would've been good targets for this. 2022 offseason had an unusual number of offer sheet eligible RFAs that signed small dollar contracts.
To some degree, it's a step short of collusion in that you don't want to set a certain bar for your upcoming RFAs. If you give Kakko 4 million, then what is Dawson Mercer's agent asking for when he's RFA?
I'm curious if there's quietly any annoyance by Martin Necas who had to settle for a two year, 3 mil AAV deal. Carolina offer sheeted Jesperi Kotkaniemi for 6.1 mil then gave him a 8 year extension for 38.5 mil. Necas' next contract negotiation might be an interesting one if they don't give him the same red carpet treatment.
It wasn't an offer sheet, but I'm also reminded of when the Pegulas first took over the Sabres. They went on a spending spree for Christian Ehrhoff and Ville Leino while also giving Tyler Myers a fat extension. Apparently the locker room turned sour as other longer tenured Sabres felt underpaid/underappreciated.
And naturally you put a bit of a target on your back. The Kotkaniemi offer sheet was retaliatory from when Montreal signed Sebastian Aho. Vancouver offered sheeted David Backes back in the day. St. Louis matched and sent a nuisance offer sheet for Steve Bernier that Vancouver had to match (they had given up a 2nd+3rd to get Bernier from Buffalo, they would have only gotten a 2nd if they didn't match).
I'm a little surprised we don't see offer sheets on goalies more often. Ie, a team might have a hard time matching if they're already paying #1 money to somebody. Apparently Florida was worried about this scenario unfolding next summer with Spencer Knight so they gave him a healthy extension already.
Years back, San Jose gave up a 1st for Martin Jones but they could have offer sheeted him (and given up a 2nd) and Boston would have had a difficult time matching. Doug Wilson had previously offer sheeted Nik Hjalmarsson, so he had broken the seal previously.