dimi78
Registered User
- Aug 9, 2008
- 4,354
- 294
Okay... so the difference between Mac and Lombardi and Connolly is that Mac is actually a good player, and therefore has trade value.
MacA has proven himself at the NHL level, has scored 20 goals twice for us and has great chemistry with our best C. This is the difference.
The assessment of Frattin isn't wrong, people understand he's a goalscorer, but he hasn't been outstanding wit hte Marlies lately. On top of this, he's not exactly a young player... there's this stigma because he's a "prospect" that he's so young. He's older than JVR and Kadri by quite a bit, and less than a year younger than Kessel and Komarov. MacArthur is just over a year older than Frattin.
If Frattin was a great at skating, and shooting as you claim, then he would have produced more last year, and would have been producing with the Marlies. His game is off right now, sure he's got the tools but does he have the toolbox? If he gets going again in the A, he'll be back up the second there's an injury or someone falters.
Disagree, that's the type of thinking that plagues development and growth of players... Mac is a passenger to Grabovski, when Grabo go's so does Mac on the score sheet cause he's lethal from the hash marks in as a trigger guy but the rest of his game is what had him on the 4th line last year and Frattin in his role. Give it some time it wont be too long where Carlyle will land him on the bench for his play in his own end of not doing the simple task of supporting the D in getting the puck out on the wall past the blue line... Age is just a number my dear friend look at experience when you want to break it down what Frattin is in need of and the confidence you gain when your an NHL regular what it does for your game.
Everybody including the greatest hockey player of all time go's through ups and downs this standard that young guys have to be going at all times over the vet to make your club is how you ruin prospects. As much as people don't get it when it comes to youth it's about projection and do they show the signs of meeting them that Frattin has more than anything else to get them in the NHL when your a bottom feeding team like the Leafs... development as an NHL player doesn't occur in the AHL it happens AT THE NHL LEVEL that's why you remove the MacArthur's Lombardi's, Connoly's from your team if your going to grow your own. That's how you grow young players that are projected as part of your future you remove the vets that are nothing but road blocks and commit to the young guy to develop into what is projected of them.
Last edited by a moderator: