Talk about no proof, the above is complete conjecture. The facts are he wasn’t offer sheeted despite the fact that the Rangers were very vulnerable to it and the assets going the other direction would’ve been minimal. This speaks to the fact that the teams around the league, including much of this fan base, don’t think he’s taking that next step. I hope that’s not true but this is the evidence before us.
Does it really even matter what the league thinks? Laf is 21.
For context, Adam Fox didn't even enter the NHL until he was this age. And, despite a very good rookie year, it wasn't until Fox's second year when DeAngelo got permanently benched and Fox got PP1 time that his Norris-level play truly started.
Barring the Conor McDavids and Sidney Crosby's of the world, I'm pretty sure most GMs and coaches will admit that they really don't know whether any prospect will become a star until they actually become a star.
And even then, it only comes when giving the player the opportunity to be a star and the player making the most of it.
Bottom line is this:
Laf has gotten some of those opportunities to become a star (but not as much as other 1st overalls) and hasn't yet made the most of them. That's where we stand right now. We don't know whether that will change. It's up to both the coaching staff and Laf himself to both step it up if any improvement will happen.
Can he still be a star? Yes. But is it likely at this point? Probably a bit less than a 50/50 shot in my opinion. But that doesn't mean other teams - especially those in rebuild mode - didn't want to risk a chance on the kid. It's more that offer sheets rarely happen.
Kakko "found his place" scoring exactly one point more than Lafreniere while being a year older... Lafreniere scored 19 even strength goals the year prior at 20 years old while Kakko scored 18 points total.
No offense, but if you think Kakko is only "one point better" than Laf then you need your eyes checked. He's far more trustworthy and versatile than Laf at this point. And he's harder to play against. Kakko draws penalties, wins puck battles, and had some bad luck finishing chances. Laf, on the other hand, does none of those things but just finishes better.
I'd love to have more players like Kakko and less like Laf right now.