GDT: #66 - 03/11/14 | New York Rangers @ Carolina Hurricanes | 7:00 - MSG

[Thirty One]

Anything he brings in hockey he takes away in penalties.

He's a -3 in penalty differential in 39 games this season. So every 13 games he's put the Rangers net down a man once.

 

[RGY]

Wtf....why is Dorsett playing??? He absolutely blows. 4th line produces a goal and we sit Carcillo? I just dont get it. Dorsett doesnt deserve to be out there

 

[Ail]

He's a -3 in penalty differential in 39 games this season. So every 13 games he's put the Rangers net down a man once.

That's ****ing disgusting! Ugh. Bury him in the minors ****ing scrub.

 

[Killem Dafoe]

Dorsett was a fan favorite in Columbus.

 

[Thirty One]

Wtf....why is Dorsett playing??? He absolutely blows. 4th line produces a goal and we sit Carcillo? I just dont get it. Dorsett doesnt deserve to be out there

Carcillo's contribution to that goal consisted of him possibly going offside on the entry.

 

[LORENZO]

Dorsett was a fan favorite in Columbus.

Says it all.

 

[shoves]

When you're a 4th liner, I'd rather you not give it your all than take stupid penalties. These cliches about giving your all are getting annoying. Who cares if you're giving it your all if you're a liability. Also Richards is one of our leading scorers and Nash is our leading goal scorer (minus MSL), I wish Dorsett didn't give it his all like them. Those guys produce, Dorsett doesn't and he takes bad penalties to boot. Time to treat these guys like adults and not like kids who get a medal for trying.

Well, if he gets a goal and some confidence, im sure he will cool down and stop overtrying. And if you say Dorsett doesnt produce no defence or forechecking, youre wrong.

Yes i know the stats. Dont get brainwashed by the stats, then you might aswell stop watching the games and just check highlights. I jugde the player based on what they put out on the ice. Richards and Nash' seasons has not been acceptable. **** the stats.

 

[Hunter Gathers]

Yes. Also: hockey.

Not this season.

 

[Thirty One]

Dorsett was a fan favorite in Columbus.

Dorsett was drafted in the 7th round by Columbus in 2006. Same round as Arturs Kulda. Latvia. Dorsett first become arbitration-eligible in 2010. He is a Sagittarius. Archery.

 

[ecemleafs]

Nobody likes car bomb and always want to hit him.... so they worry about him instead of the game itself... Nobody gives a ***** about door-sit! And car bomb has scored some important goals for us

carcillo has 2 points in 21 games for us. dorsett has 5 in 39 games. offense is clearly not in the equation with these 2.

 

[Hunter Gathers]

Dorsett was a fan favorite in Columbus.

Dorsett was a fan favorite in Columbus.

in Columbus.

in Columbus.

That's the problem.

 

[Ail]

Dorsett was drafted in the 7th round by Columbus in 2006. Same round as Arturs Kulda. Latvia. Dorsett first become arbitration-eligible in 2010. He is a Sagittarius. Archery.

What college, doe?

 

[Ail]

That's the problem.

Prust was a fan favorite in a place as bad, or worse. Were they wrong too?

 

[AHB*]

He's a -3 in penalty differential in 39 games this season. So every 13 games he's put the Rangers net down a man once.

May be true, but those penalties are often moronic ones. Hence the Philly game recently and the St. Louis game to start the season.

His penalties have been costly and unecessary.

Carcillo is also a much better skater and pushes the offense much more on that 4th line. Why are we messing with a good thing? Especially for a plug like Dorsett.

 

[BroadwayStorm]

Hat Trick for St. Louis!

 

[Killem Dafoe]

lol those responses...

 

[Thirty One]

carcillo has 2 points in 21 games for us. dorsett has 5 in 39 games. offense is clearly not in the equation with these 2.

It's far less in the equation for one of them.

Dorsett's 5-on-5 points per 60 is 0.81 this season. Carcillo's is 0.44.

 

[Inferno]

Carcillo > Door-stop, go with the strongest lineup, oh sorry, I forgot these are the Rangers...

by that rationalization, Henrik>Talbot for his career,

or

Talbot>Henrik for this year

So one should be playing 82 games, the other should be sitting 82 games, depending on which you hold to be true.


Or, maybe, Dorsett has been a MUCH better player his entire career compared to Carcillo, and just needs to get back into things.

Before his injury, Dorsett was a very effective player for us, and playing much better than Carcillo is now. Granted, Carcillo has been much better than Dorsett since the break.

i'm fine with this.

 

[Jersey Girl]

Hat Trick for St. Louis!

Let's start with one and go from there. Time to join the party, Marty.

 

[Amazing Kreiderman]

Cue the Dorsett hattie....

Is that a minor penalty, a major penalty and a game misconduct?

 

[jskramer83]

That's the problem.

Forbes did give Columbus an "A" as a place to go for career and #3 on relocation, so Durrrrrr-sett did it all wrong.

 

[Thirty One]

May be true, but those penalties are often moronic ones. Hence the Philly game recently and the St. Louis game to start the season.

His penalties have been costly and unecessary.

Carcillo is also a much better skater and pushes the offense much more on that 4th line. Why are we messing with a good thing? Especially for a plug like Dorsett.

Because Carcillo is not a good thing. He's a bad thing.

 

[Vickers8]

by that rationalization, Henrik>Talbot for his career,

or

Talbot>Henrik for this year

So one should be playing 82 games, the other should be sitting 82 games, depending on which you hold to be true.


Or, maybe, Dorsett has been a MUCH better player his entire career compared to Carcillo, and just needs to get back into things.

Before his injury, Dorsett was a very effective player for us, and playing much better than Carcillo is now. Granted, Carcillo has been much better than Dorsett since the break.

i'm fine with this.

Teams winning leave the lineup alone, you think Dorsett is better good for you, I think Carcillo is better

 

[Vickers8]

Because Carcillo is not a good thing. He's a bad thing.

In fairness to carcillo he has played very disciplined since he came and we have been winning

 

[Thirty One]

by that rationalization, Henrik>Talbot for his career,

or

Talbot>Henrik for this year

So one should be playing 82 games, the other should be sitting 82 games, depending on which you hold to be true.


Or, maybe, Dorsett has been a MUCH better player his entire career compared to Carcillo, and just needs to get back into things.

Before his injury, Dorsett was a very effective player for us, and playing much better than Carcillo is now. Granted, Carcillo has been much better than Dorsett since the break.

i'm fine with this.

Yeah, the only way Carcillo is better than Dorsett is if you cut it down into comically small sample sizes.