Blue Jays GDT: 2024 v6 | Fri, Sept 13 | vs StL | 7pm ET/4pm PT | TBA vs TBA Ohtanis Makes History

Suntouchable13

Registered User
Dec 20, 2003
44,515
20,692
Toronto, ON
I think Vladdy, Bo being Bo, a big bat (via FA or trade), and Horwitz is a good hitting core. If they can get 2 legit bats, even better. Tigers have a bunch of slightly above average hitters looking at their OPS+ and one starting pitcher and they are in the playoffs. There’s definitely a path to contention next year.
 

Dr Pepper

Registered User
Dec 9, 2005
71,378
17,039
Sunny Etobicoke
I think Vladdy, Bo being Bo, a big bat (via FA or trade), and Horwitz is a good hitting core. If they can get 2 legit bats, even better. Tigers have a bunch of slightly above average hitters looking at their OPS+ and one starting pitcher and they are in the playoffs. There’s definitely a path to contention next year.

1727899667496.png


Neat little factoid I came across the other day......and at the same time rather depressing because Detroit's still playing and the Jays aren't. :laugh:

The Jays, aside from Vladdy going beast mode, seemed like a team chock-full of utility players just trying to make a go of it.

Horwitz, Clement, Barger, Wagner, De Los Santos, Loperfido, and let's not forget Davis Schneider having the slumpiest season there ever was.

Who's the everyday 3B next season? How about 2B?

Atkins has his work cut out for him.....but at this point I wouldn't trust him to plan a two-car parade.

Hope he's got a plan.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Suntouchable13

henryasteroidlionnet

Registered User
May 4, 2024
91
75

Atkins on offensive needs: "Power is low-hanging fruit to add. In today's game, you have to be cognizant of strikeouts when you do do that." Also says contact is "exceptionally important" in the playoffs, so "not as simple as plug in a power bat" unless they're versatile.​


Four of the six division winners are in the top 10 for home runs hit in 2024.

The Jays are 26th.

Want to talk about playing the game today, Ross? Home runs are absolutely a central part of it.

Get this clown out of here, please.
 

Dr Pepper

Registered User
Dec 9, 2005
71,378
17,039
Sunny Etobicoke

Atkins on offensive needs: "Power is low-hanging fruit to add. In today's game, you have to be cognizant of strikeouts when you do do that." Also says contact is "exceptionally important" in the playoffs, so "not as simple as plug in a power bat" unless they're versatile.​


Four of the six division winners are in the top 10 for home runs hit in 2024.

The Jays are 26th.

Want to talk about playing the game today, Ross? Home runs are absolutely a central part of it.

Get this clown out of here, please.

No doubt he's kept an eye on the many Jays fans online pushing to take a run at Soto in the offseason.

His response is probably Atkins' clumsy way of pouring cold water on that idea. :shakehead
 
Last edited:

Discoverer

Registered User
Apr 11, 2012
11,233
6,589
No doubt he's kept an eye on the many Jays fans online pushing to take a run at Soto in the offseason.

His response is probably Atkins' clumsy way of pouring cold water on that idea. :shakehead
I... don't get it. If anything, when he says you want to add power while being cognizant of strikeouts, he's literally describing Soto.
 

Dr Pepper

Registered User
Dec 9, 2005
71,378
17,039
Sunny Etobicoke
I... don't get it. If anything, when he says you want to add power while being cognizant of strikeouts, he's literally describing Soto.

Hey if the Jays manage to land Soto this winter I'll applaud Atkins like everyone else. Huge move.

But to me his quote came across as more of a "we're going to build internally" type of approach as opposed to targeting the big fish on the market.
 

Suntouchable13

Registered User
Dec 20, 2003
44,515
20,692
Toronto, ON
Hey if the Jays manage to land Soto this winter I'll applaud Atkins like everyone else. Huge move.

But to me his quote came across as more of a "we're going to build internally" type of approach as opposed to targeting the big fish on the market.

That doesn't compute to me, though. They tried that past off season. What I got from Atkins is that they know they f***ed up and they will obsessive about trying to improve. I 100% believe they will target big free agents.
 

Dr Pepper

Registered User
Dec 9, 2005
71,378
17,039
Sunny Etobicoke
That doesn't compute to me, though. They tried that past off season. What I got from Atkins is that they know they f***ed up and they will obsessive about trying to improve. I 100% believe they will target big free agents.

Hope so. If their jobs weren't on the line last season - miraculously - they sure as hell are now.

At least one would like to think so, anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Suntouchable13

GoonieFace

Registered User
Jun 24, 2013
7,843
8,075
The Matrix
Hope so. If their jobs weren't on the line last season - miraculously - they sure as hell are now.

At least one would like to think so, anyway.
They have always pursued big free agents: Springer, Gausman and Ryu were probably the biggest names on the market their respective seasons. They went hard on Ohtani as well. There just wasn’t much there last off season.

No way Soto signs here, so let’s forget about that. Let’s see a bold baseball trade.
 

Dr Pepper

Registered User
Dec 9, 2005
71,378
17,039
Sunny Etobicoke
They have always pursued big free agents: Springer, Gausman and Ryu were probably the biggest names on the market their respective seasons. They went hard on Ohtani as well. There just wasn’t much there last off season.

No way Soto signs here, so let’s forget about that. Let’s see a bold baseball trade.

I'd settle for a Vladdy extension announcement, if we're looking at positive news this offseason.

Not expecting that anytime soon but hopefully before spring training anyway.

As for "bold baseball trades", who'd you have in mind? Reliable bullpen arm or power-hitting 3B?
 

Kurtz

Registered User
Jul 17, 2005
10,379
7,451
players dont want to come here.
I dont remember a good offseason in a long time.

I don't get the same impression. This isn't the NHL where players may want to avoid us because of all the fan and media scrutiny or the NBA where Americans may not want to play in the frozen north. In MLB it seems to be all about the benjamins. Ie Springer left a perennial contender in a nice city to come here because we offered him a little bit more aav and an extra year.
 

Discoverer

Registered User
Apr 11, 2012
11,233
6,589
I don't get the same impression. This isn't the NHL where players may want to avoid us because of all the fan and media scrutiny or the NBA where Americans may not want to play in the frozen north. In MLB it seems to be all about the benjamins. Ie Springer left a perennial contender in a nice city to come here because we offered him a little bit more aav and an extra year.
Yeah, the "players don't want to come here" thing should have been dead a long time ago.
 

HamiltonNHL

Resigning Marner == Running it back
Jan 4, 2012
22,710
13,884
I don't get the same impression.
Well, the results are the results.

We have the money, but almost NEVER attract top end talent and we seem not to draft well on top of it.

How many failing players came here, reclaimed their form, and left ?

Guys also seem to want a premium to stay.

Yeah, the "players don't want to come here" thing should have been dead a long time ago.
why dont they come then?

even players that kinda want to stay ... hard ball management and the deal falls through (Robbie Ray).

players don't like the cold weather, dont like astroturf, dont like the dome, dont like the taxes.
 

LaP

Registered User
Jun 27, 2012
26,118
20,297
Quebec City, Canada
I think Vladdy, Bo being Bo, a big bat (via FA or trade), and Horwitz is a good hitting core. If they can get 2 legit bats, even better. Tigers have a bunch of slightly above average hitters looking at their OPS+ and one starting pitcher and they are in the playoffs. There’s definitely a path to contention next year.
Their number 1 pitcher was super dominant though. Their offense is pretty meh and not better than the Jays. But they got a good bullpen and one of the most dominant number 1 starter in baseball. The guy had a whip under 1 in almost 200 innings. I would not try to replicate that personally it's kind of a rare exception it's probably one of the worst offense to ever make the playoffs.
 

Discoverer

Registered User
Apr 11, 2012
11,233
6,589
Well, the results are the results.

We have the money, but almost NEVER attract top end talent and we seem not to draft well on top of it.

How many failing players came here, reclaimed their form, and left ?

Guys also seem to want a premium to stay.


why dont they come then?
In the last five offseasons, they signed one of the best available free agents three times (Ryu, Springer, Gausman). Bassitt wasn't quite on that level, but he was a good one, too.

Those are the results. How many of the top free agents does a team need to add to be considered somewhere that players want to sign?
 

LaP

Registered User
Jun 27, 2012
26,118
20,297
Quebec City, Canada

Atkins on offensive needs: "Power is low-hanging fruit to add. In today's game, you have to be cognizant of strikeouts when you do do that." Also says contact is "exceptionally important" in the playoffs, so "not as simple as plug in a power bat" unless they're versatile.​


Four of the six division winners are in the top 10 for home runs hit in 2024.

The Jays are 26th.

Want to talk about playing the game today, Ross? Home runs are absolutely a central part of it.

Get this clown out of here, please.
I wish the "not as simple as plug in a power bat unless they're versatile" would also come with "contact is exceptionally important in the playoffs as long as you can run the bases too".

The main problem with Atkins team is it can't run. He's trying to play small ball with guys who are slower on base than my 84 years old mom. Only way it works is if the pitching is top 5 in baseball.
 

Suntouchable13

Registered User
Dec 20, 2003
44,515
20,692
Toronto, ON
Their number 1 pitcher was super dominant though. Their offense is pretty meh and not better than the Jays. But they got a good bullpen and one of the most dominant number 1 starter in baseball. The guy had a whip under 1 in almost 200 innings. I would not try to replicate that personally it's kind of a rare exception it's probably one of the worst offense to ever make the playoffs.

But what I mean is we have a good rotation, more than just 1 good starter. That's a pretty good base right there. And we have a Vladdy.

I don't get the same impression. This isn't the NHL where players may want to avoid us because of all the fan and media scrutiny or the NBA where Americans may not want to play in the frozen north. In MLB it seems to be all about the benjamins. Ie Springer left a perennial contender in a nice city to come here because we offered him a little bit more aav and an extra year.

Well, we have a nice city too (summer time especially) and we had an up coming team with Vladdy and Bo.
 

barilko05

People...they're the worst!
Jan 28, 2011
1,169
923
Well, the results are the results.

We have the money, but almost NEVER attract top end talent and we seem not to draft well on top of it.

How many failing players came here, reclaimed their form, and left ?

Guys also seem to want a premium to stay.


why dont they come then?

even players that kinda want to stay ... hard ball management and the deal falls through (Robbie Ray).

players don't like the cold weather, dont like astroturf, dont like the dome, dont like the taxes.
You're shittin' me, right? COLD? First off, we play in a dome! 2nd, it's probably warmer here in the spring, summer, and even parts of the winter, than in half a dozen other MLB cities. Milwaukee, Minny, Detroit, Cleveland, etc. Also, I would suggest most players don't even live here in the off season. Now, the tax situation...that's another story. But if you're making 10+ mil a year, and you don't have a money guy figuring out how to shelter that cash, then you're dumber than a post and probably actually believe we all live in igloos and drive polar bears to work, anyway.
 

Dr Pepper

Registered User
Dec 9, 2005
71,378
17,039
Sunny Etobicoke
I wish the "not as simple as plug in a power bat unless they're versatile" would also come with "contact is exceptionally important in the playoffs as long as you can run the bases too".

The main problem with Atkins team is it can't run. He's trying to play small ball with guys who are slower on base than my 84 years old mom. Only way it works is if the pitching is top 5 in baseball.

I feel like the Jays' starting rotation was one of the few bright spots on the season, even if it was a bit of a dip for Gausman.

The bullpen, on the other hand. :help:

Agreed with your comment regarding speed on the basepaths though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LaP

LaP

Registered User
Jun 27, 2012
26,118
20,297
Quebec City, Canada
You're shittin' me, right? COLD? First off, we play in a dome! 2nd, it's probably warmer here in the spring, summer, and even parts of the winter, than in half a dozen other MLB cities. Milwaukee, Minny, Detroit, Cleveland, etc. Also, I would suggest most players don't even live here in the off season. Now, the tax situation...that's another story. But if you're making 10+ mil a year, and you don't have a money guy figuring out how to shelter that cash, then you're dumber than a post and probably actually believe we all live in igloos and drive polar bears to work, anyway.
Most MLB players are not canadians. I'm not a tax specialist but not sure they are paying the full amount of taxes in canada.
 

henryasteroidlionnet

Registered User
May 4, 2024
91
75
We ditched Teoscar.

And never replaced him. That’s been a few years now.
They tried replacing him with a 39-year-old, Justin Turner. We all saw how that worked out. LOL. This front office has no clue what they are doing. They did not have a plan B after missing out on Ohtani. They have failed us. Nine years of nothing. Time for them to go! Rogers needs to grow a pair and just do it. Most of us Blue Jays fans are not happy. I know many people who do not plan to watch this team next season as long as this FO is still in charge.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: HamiltonNHL

stats1

Registered User
Jul 22, 2022
2,630
2,453
Well, the results are the results.

We have the money, but almost NEVER attract top end talent and we seem not to draft well on top of it.

How many failing players came here, reclaimed their form, and left ?

Guys also seem to want a premium to stay.


why dont they come then?

even players that kinda want to stay ... hard ball management and the deal falls through (Robbie Ray).

players don't like the cold weather, dont like astroturf, dont like the dome, dont like the taxes.
They literally play in the summer lol… 😂 players don’t have to stay here when fall arrives unless you’re in the playoffs. And even then we play in a dome. Don’t give me “players don’t like the cold B.S.
 
  • Like
Reactions: barilko05

GoonieFace

Registered User
Jun 24, 2013
7,843
8,075
The Matrix
I'd settle for a Vladdy extension announcement, if we're looking at positive news this offseason.

Not expecting that anytime soon but hopefully before spring training anyway.

As for "bold baseball trades", who'd you have in mind? Reliable bullpen arm or power-hitting 3B?
Really depends on what they do with Bo. They could trade him for a starting pitcher perhaps or an outfield bat. Sign Adames to play short and have Clement at 3rd.

They have a logjam of infielders that may have some value in a trade (Jimenez, Barger).

The bullpen needs a complete overhaul as well. Lots of work to do
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr Pepper

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad