Blue Jays Discussion: 2024 Season - Complete without a great title in keeping with the performance

Status
Not open for further replies.

hockeywiz542

Registered User
May 26, 2008
16,335
5,348

ESPN's Buster Olney thinks that Houston Astros third baseman Alex Bregman could be a key name in play.

Olney joined First Up on TSN1050 on Tuesday morning to discuss the chances the Blue Jays make a move on Bregman, and what other teams could be in play for the veteran.

"He's a proven winner, he's a really good third baseman, he can hit, he would help to lengthen out their lineup," Olney said.

Bregman, 30, is coming off the final season of a five-year, $100 million deal signed with the Astros. The two-time All-Star has received Most Valuable Player votes in four of his nine MLB seasons, and was a member of both the 2017 and 2022 World Series champion teams.

He finished the 2024 campaign with a .260 batting average and 26 home runs, 75 runs batted in and 79 runs scored.

"We know the Blue Jays have been looking to fill the third base spot more permanently for the past couple of years," Olney said.

"They made [former Blue Jays third baseman] Matt Chapman [an] offer for about $125 million early in the 2023 season, and Bregman fits [the team's needs] in a lot of ways."


Toronto's 4.14 runs scored per game ranked 23rd in the MLB this season. They scored one or fewer runs in 32 games last season, which accounted for 31 of their 88 losses.

Per FanGraphs, the Blue Jays ranked 20th in home runs hit by third basemen (16), 22nd in runs scored (66) and tied for 18th in wins above replacement (2.1) in 2024.

Bregman is expected to be one of the most attractive pieces on the market in free agency this winter, and the Blue Jays will have no shortage of competition in acquiring his services, according to Olney.

"Here's the thing: Not only does Houston want him back - and I do think there are limits to what the Astros can offer him - but there's another team that's on the rise in the American League that also could use a third baseman, and that would be the Detroit Tigers."


"They are managed by A.J. Hinch, who was Bregman's manager in Houston. They've got a lot of payroll flexibility ... I think, given their late-season success, given the excellence of their players and what they're building there, and given Hinch's influence, it wouldn't at all surprise me if they made a run at Alex as someone who could be an anchor for these young players on the Tigers," Olney said.
 

Bjindaho

Registered User
Jun 12, 2006
7,287
1,988

ESPN's Buster Olney thinks that Houston Astros third baseman Alex Bregman could be a key name in play.

Olney joined First Up on TSN1050 on Tuesday morning to discuss the chances the Blue Jays make a move on Bregman, and what other teams could be in play for the veteran.

"He's a proven winner, he's a really good third baseman, he can hit, he would help to lengthen out their lineup," Olney said.

Bregman, 30, is coming off the final season of a five-year, $100 million deal signed with the Astros. The two-time All-Star has received Most Valuable Player votes in four of his nine MLB seasons, and was a member of both the 2017 and 2022 World Series champion teams.

He finished the 2024 campaign with a .260 batting average and 26 home runs, 75 runs batted in and 79 runs scored.

"We know the Blue Jays have been looking to fill the third base spot more permanently for the past couple of years," Olney said.

"They made [former Blue Jays third baseman] Matt Chapman [an] offer for about $125 million early in the 2023 season, and Bregman fits [the team's needs] in a lot of ways."


Toronto's 4.14 runs scored per game ranked 23rd in the MLB this season. They scored one or fewer runs in 32 games last season, which accounted for 31 of their 88 losses.

Per FanGraphs, the Blue Jays ranked 20th in home runs hit by third basemen (16), 22nd in runs scored (66) and tied for 18th in wins above replacement (2.1) in 2024.

Bregman is expected to be one of the most attractive pieces on the market in free agency this winter, and the Blue Jays will have no shortage of competition in acquiring his services, according to Olney.

"Here's the thing: Not only does Houston want him back - and I do think there are limits to what the Astros can offer him - but there's another team that's on the rise in the American League that also could use a third baseman, and that would be the Detroit Tigers."


"They are managed by A.J. Hinch, who was Bregman's manager in Houston. They've got a lot of payroll flexibility ... I think, given their late-season success, given the excellence of their players and what they're building there, and given Hinch's influence, it wouldn't at all surprise me if they made a run at Alex as someone who could be an anchor for these young players on the Tigers," Olney said.
He's an interesting option.

Soto has to be #1 on any list (because he's Soto). After that, Toronto could look at Bregman, Alonso and Christian Walker as the next tier (where Vladdy shifts to 3B for the latter 2).
 
  • Like
Reactions: hockeywiz542

Discoverer

Registered User
Apr 11, 2012
11,399
6,873
Juan Soto named a gold glove finalist like honest what tf are we even doing here at this point.
Over the last few years, the Gold Gloves seem to be a bit more meaningful since they seem to be based more on actual performance than reputation/offensive ability. We don't seem to get as many Jeter (won multiple Gold Gloves while being arguably the worst defensive SS in the game) or Palmeiro (full time DH, won a Gold Glove playing 28 games at 1B) situations anymore.

Hell, I can even accept that the best defensive player in baseball the last two years likely won't end up with a single Gold Glove because of where he's played.

This one, though? This isn't far off Jeter level. Among the 30 AL players with at least 200 innings in RF, he finish 21st in DRS (-1), 28th in OAA (-5.5), and 30th - dead last - in UZR (-6).

Abreu's going to win it anyway, so it won't matter, but that's no reason to nominate one of the worst in the league for an award.

(Also, Kirk absolutely deserved a nomination.)
 

Bjindaho

Registered User
Jun 12, 2006
7,287
1,988
Over the last few years, the Gold Gloves seem to be a bit more meaningful since they seem to be based more on actual performance than reputation/offensive ability. We don't seem to get as many Jeter (won multiple Gold Gloves while being arguably the worst defensive SS in the game) or Palmeiro (full time DH, won a Gold Glove playing 28 games at 1B) situations anymore.

Hell, I can even accept that the best defensive player in baseball the last two years likely won't end up with a single Gold Glove because of where he's played.

This one, though? This isn't far off Jeter level. Among the 30 AL players with at least 200 innings in RF, he finish 21st in DRS (-1), 28th in OAA (-5.5), and 30th - dead last - in UZR (-6).

Abreu's going to win it anyway, so it won't matter, but that's no reason to nominate one of the worst in the league for an award.

(Also, Kirk absolutely deserved a nomination.)
By SABR's Defensive Index, Soto was 3rd for RF as of Aug 11.

Also, Kirk was 4th for C.
 

Bjindaho

Registered User
Jun 12, 2006
7,287
1,988
It should be noted that the SABR system is based on Zone Rating, UZR, TZR, Runs Effectively Defended and DRS (the original)
 

Discoverer

Registered User
Apr 11, 2012
11,399
6,873
It should be noted that the SABR system is based on Zone Rating, UZR, TZR, Runs Effectively Defended and DRS (the original)
I'd love to know more about how they incorporate that information. It also says they use Statcast data. DRS, UZR, and Statcast all have Soto as one of the worst in the league.
 

Bjindaho

Registered User
Jun 12, 2006
7,287
1,988
I'd love to know more about how they incorporate that information. It also says they use Statcast data. DRS, UZR, and Statcast all have Soto as one of the worst in the league.
UZR, Runs Effectively Defended and TZR are Statcast-based.

FWIW, I posted many times this year railing on the use of these stats for catchers (because they suck).

TZR had Soto 20th.

Here's the full description:
 

Bjindaho

Registered User
Jun 12, 2006
7,287
1,988
It should be noted that if you are looking at the criteria and saying to yourself, "this seems problematic", you aren't going crazy.

25% of the gold glove decisions is based on SABR (whose formulas pick and pull from available data but blatantly ignore other points because they weren't devised by them or Bill James. As a result, framing gets no value (Kirk was 2nd in framing in baseball, while Fremin is a negative value framer) and there is no attention paid to home park (in other words, Soto gets a huge boost from playing in a couple of parks where extra balls go out of play that he couldn't get to but a decent RF could).
 

Suntouchable13

Registered User
Dec 20, 2003
44,866
21,261
Toronto, ON
He's an interesting option.

Soto has to be #1 on any list (because he's Soto). After that, Toronto could look at Bregman, Alonso and Christian Walker as the next tier (where Vladdy shifts to 3B for the latter 2).

Vladdy needs to be first piece of business done. You can't sign guys while Vladdy and Bo could walk in one year. Why would a free agent come here, commit to the Blue Jays, with that uncertainty?
 

MK78

Registered User
Apr 8, 2023
2,538
1,736
Vladdy needs to be first piece of business done. You can't sign guys while Vladdy and Bo could walk in one year. Why would a free agent come here, commit to the Blue Jays, with that uncertainty?
Why would Soto even come here. he's slamming bombs alongside Judge in NY. If he signs there long term the endorsements potential is gonna be huge, not to mention the Yanks are always competitive and don't have a "Canadian problem" in attracting free agents.

He'll probably do the same thing Ohtani did, play the Jays for fools and drive up the price from NY.
 

TheBeastCoast

Registered User
Mar 23, 2011
32,889
34,385
Dartmouth,NS
Why would Soto even come here. he's slamming bombs alongside Judge in NY. If he signs there long term the endorsements potential is gonna be huge, not to mention the Yanks are always competitive and don't have a "Canadian problem" in attracting free agents.

He'll probably do the same thing Ohtani did, play the Jays for fools and drive up the price from NY.
I am okay with driving the price up with NY. The thing you can't do is actually put your eggs in that basket...go pursue your actual target while driving the price up with Soto and if for whatever reason Soto doesn't get it from NY...sure.
 

GoonieFace

Registered User
Jun 24, 2013
8,170
8,571
The Matrix
Why would Soto even come here. he's slamming bombs alongside Judge in NY. If he signs there long term the endorsements potential is gonna be huge, not to mention the Yanks are always competitive and don't have a "Canadian problem" in attracting free agents.

He'll probably do the same thing Ohtani did, play the Jays for fools and drive up the price from NY.
Yeah the Jays haven’t attracted any free agents the past few years, for shame
 

MK78

Registered User
Apr 8, 2023
2,538
1,736
Yeah the Jays haven’t attracted any free agents the past few years, for shame
Well no, they have to some extent, and have gotten some decent signings in the starting pitching department... but the hitters haven't worked out.

But there have been reports over the years that players didnt wanna come to Canada to play.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hockeywiz542

Lightsol

Registered User
Aug 2, 2005
5,385
3,390
The MLB appears to have devolved back to the George Steinbrenner era; to win, you have to spent $300 million a year on your roster. Of the four remaining teams, the only one that isn't in the top 3 in payroll is Cleveland, and they're down 3-0.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hockeywiz542

shaner8989

Registered User
Aug 6, 2005
23,703
5,888
Clase is a joke. Can’t handle the pressure at all. He’s a type of guy you avoid when building a winner. Absolutely pathetic playoff after a dominant season.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad