Toggle sidebar

HF Habs: 2024 NHL Draft Thread

  • Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates

Who do you want at #5?

  • Tij Iginla

    Votes: 209 49.5%

  • Cole Eiserman

    Votes: 14 3.3%

  • Berkly Catton

    Votes: 92 21.8%

  • Konsta Helenius

    Votes: 13 3.1%

  • Beckett Sennecke

    Votes: 75 17.8%

  • Zayne Parekh

    Votes: 19 4.5%
  • Total voters
    422
Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
montreal said:
his ppg is right there with Andrew Cristall's from last season, who I know some on here liked last year but he dropped.
Click to expand...

I liked Cristall almost until the end, but I had to admit his game is far from pro ready and at some point couldn't justify a top 15 pick on someone like that. Good reminder that stats alone are not a good way to justify players on draft day.

Not that I think they are comparable prospects: I think Catton is considerably more likely to make the NHL just based off his skating advantage alone. Will come down to building physical strength and d-zone adjustments for him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: morhilane, skidcells, MarkovsKnee and 1 other person
GlassesJacketShirt said:
I liked Cristall almost until the end, but I had to admit his game is far from pro ready and at some point couldn't justify a top 15 pick on someone like that. Good reminder that stats alone are not a good way to justify players on draft day.

Not that I think they are comparable prospects: I think Catton is considerably more likely to make the NHL just based off his skating advantage alone. Will come down to building physical strength and d-zone adjustments for him.
Click to expand...
Yes, Catton play could play in the pro tomorrow and not look bad at all other than being severely under sized.
Cristall would get exposed in the pro, big time, (his jump to the AHL will be very interesting) they don't have much comparable. I will say that Cristall has slightly better hands though.

Scouting based on pure stats is always very wrong.
 
Last edited:
montreal said:
his ppg is right there with Andrew Cristall's from last season, who I know some on here liked last year but he dropped.
Click to expand...

Cristall dropped because his skating isn't up to par. Great edges & balance though. He's also small. Smaller than Catton.

Catton has no physical game to speak of, and he needs to gain weight/strength. He's really weak. He's a rush player only at this stage.

There's lots to work with, though. The question is how much will Catton commit to improving his game, getting stronger and adding some physical elements? He played wing last year, and I wasn't crazy about him. He's a center this year and it allows him more use of the ice. Problem is, I don't see him as a center in NHL.
 
  • Like
Reactions: montreal
Maybe it’s not a bad thing if Kelowna gets eliminated quick, maybe Iginla will be in time for the U18.
 
Pompeius Magnus said:
Hard not to be want Buium after the frozen four, not gonna lie. I could live with going with another dman with the early first and a forward with the later one, even if I know a lot of people will cringe at it. You have to take the best player at some point.
Click to expand...
Trading Hutson is an option. Buium has the profile to be a norris D winner. He's not small, he's fast, he's skilled, he can defend, he produces... There's like... nothing aside from him being a left shot.
montreal said:
his ppg is right there with Andrew Cristall's from last season, who I know some on here liked last year but he dropped.
Click to expand...
Cristall was one of my favorite last draft but I even couldn't justify having him this high. Both are cherry-picking little shits, even though I love them.

It's really just that the WHL is really a terrible environment for development.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Locks and GlassesJacketShirt
Mrb1p said:
Trading Hutson is an option. Buium has the profile to be a norris D winner. He's not small, he's fast, he's skilled, he can defend, he produces... There's like... nothing aside from him being a left shot.
Click to expand...

Won't say he'll win a Norris, that is a massive expectation to place on an 18 year old, but agreed his skillset and playstyle are the most reminiscent of many of today's minute-munching, offensively skilled defensemen who tilt the ice in their team's favor on a nightly basis without being a headache defensively. Give him good coaching and he'll be a No. 1 somewhere.
 
Shutdown said:
kid who used a racial slur against an opponent, where there's video of the player having to be consoled by his coach, draws a swastika a year later - "doesn't mean he's racist and you're intellectually lazy to argue it".
Click to expand...
I definitely wouldn’t draft the kid who had to be consoled by some kid uttering something stupid. I’ve heard all sorts of trash talk playing sports, and some of it was obviously quite nasty and meant to get others off their game. Not defending being able to say whatever you want to others, but just underlining the value of thick skin and reselience. I can’t imagine hearing anything from my competitors that would affect me emotionally.
 
Bacchus1 said:
I definitely wouldn’t draft the kid who had to be consoled by some kid uttering something stupid. I’ve heard all sorts of trash talk playing sports, and some of it was obviously quite nasty and meant to get others off their game. Not defending being able to say whatever you want to others, but just underlining the value of thick skin and reselience. I can’t imagine hearing anything from my competitors that would affect me emotionally.
Click to expand...
It was a child that happened to.
That's not what you should be taking from this
 
  • Like
Reactions: David Suzuki, RandomTask26, le_sean and 2 others
Playmaker09 said:
His handling has such high highs and low lows. He'll dangle though three guys, then the next shift will turn it over twice while handling the puck like a grenade.

PG has shut out Kelowna all 4 periods of the series and counting. Kelowna has 6 shots almost halfway through the game.
Maybe the criticisms of Catton were a little harsh?
Click to expand...

I observed exactly what you said, and other people have told me that he has exceptional hands. I don't buy it.
1635454847-elton-john-tison-golem.png


Pompeius Magnus said:
Hard not to want Buium after the frozen four, not gonna lie. I could live with going with another dman with the early first and a forward with the later one, even if I know a lot of people will cringe at it. You have to take the best player at some point.
Click to expand...

Demidov, Catton or a defensman... And obviously Celebrini.
1635454847-elton-john-tison-golem.png
 
Bacchus1 said:
I definitely wouldn’t draft the kid who had to be consoled by some kid uttering something stupid. I’ve heard all sorts of trash talk playing sports, and some of it was obviously quite nasty and meant to get others off their game. Not defending being able to say whatever you want to others, but just underlining the value of thick skin and reselience. I can’t imagine hearing anything from my competitors that would affect me emotionally.
Click to expand...
Good lord! Here we go with some unnecessary and pointless victim blaming. I've seen grown men at the pro level get emotional after being victims of a racial slur. The irony that you use "thick skin" to try to make your point.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: RandomTask26, Mrb1p, MasterMatt25 and 3 others
Bacchus1 said:
I definitely wouldn’t draft the kid who had to be consoled by some kid uttering something stupid. I’ve heard all sorts of trash talk playing sports, and some of it was obviously quite nasty and meant to get others off their game. Not defending being able to say whatever you want to others, but just underlining the value of thick skin and reselience. I can’t imagine hearing anything from my competitors that would affect me emotionally.
Click to expand...

Don't worry, none of us can imagine you in a competitive sports setting either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: David Suzuki, RandomTask26, Mrb1p and 2 others
JeffreyLFC said:
Nah, draft Zeev, trade Matheson and keep Hutson.
Click to expand...
I think we'd want to keep size in the rest our D. We'd be trading them both and going with Guhle Engstrom Xhekaj on LD
Buium Reinbacher Mailloux/Barron on RD
vokiel said:
When Zeev is ready for the league, Matheson won't be with us anymore.
Click to expand...
He's better than Lane Hutson right now I wouldn't worry too much about that.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom