2024 NHL Draft Thread - Upd: Draft Lottery is May 7th

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kevin Musto

Hard for Bedard
Feb 16, 2018
22,589
29,265
The players you DO want to draft is an easy list to make. The players on your DO NOT DRAFT LIST or players you don't want the Hawks to get is tougher.


What 5 players do you guys hope the Hawks don't draft?
Cole Eiserman is the obvious one to avoid in the top 5, unless he shows significant improvement in the latter half of the season.

Ivan Demidov would be the other one for me. I don't dislike the player (he's better than Eiserman), but top 5 is too high for me.
 

Darkstar

Registered User
Nov 3, 2007
648
643
Denver, CO
The players you DO want to draft is an easy list to make. The players on your DO NOT DRAFT LIST or players you don't want the Hawks to get is tougher.


What 5 players do you guys hope the Hawks don't draft?
That's a tough question because I don't really have strongly negative opinions on these prospects except Parekh and Eiserman. I will say if we don't get the 1st pick, I'd like some forwards with both size and skill like Lindstrom, Greentree and Brandsegg-Nygard. I really love the upside of Catton. Demidov and Helenius, but how are we going to build a contender without any size at forward? I wish we could have bundled a couple of our 2nd round picks in this last draft to get either Musty or Edstrom.
 

bwanajamba

Registered User
Apr 18, 2019
798
1,560
I get why Eiserman is dropping but I wonder if that particular evaluation is starting to gather too much momentum. There are concerns for sure but the kid could score 70 goals this year and he's one of the youngest players in the draft. Good skater, good hands. Certainly needs to develop other parts of his game but let's say you want to build a star from scratch, is it better to take a guy with an elite shot and scoring instincts and teach him the right way to play or take a fundamentally sound guy and hope he can learn the unteachable?

Not saying he's my choice at #2 or anything as there are obviously guys with star qualities who don't need the same degree of rounding-out, but I don't think he's a non-starter in the top five for me
 
  • Like
Reactions: ello

Castle8130

Registered User
May 9, 2017
3,025
2,537
Watching Spokane again tonight. Another three points for Catton. Great give and go assist for his third.

Just kidding, make that 4.
It's really hard to see a scenario where he doesn't succeed at the NHL level. He's always one of the best players on the ice
 

crazyhawk

Registered User
Apr 8, 2011
2,958
1,379
In the Hills
Tampa sits currently at the 15th OA pick so there is a slight possibility Eiserman is still there.
However depending upon who else is still available may lead the Hawks elsewhere.
 

clydesdale line

Connor BeJesus
Jan 10, 2012
25,478
24,212
Unless there is an absolute run on defenseman (which is certainly possible given GMs having massive hard ons about taking big defenseman even if they're projected later on) there is next to 0 shot Eiserman lasts that long. There's a much better chance Demidov slips cuz of the Russian factor than Eiserman.
 

hawksfan50

Registered User
Feb 27, 2002
14,508
2,081
It is lovely to imagine Euserman with his goal scoring talent on the Pp...BUT
.Hawks cannot get out of their own zone...so 5x5 he is going to be checked and stymied and chasing a lot in our own zone..not getting enough tome in o-zobe..Plus
..like likecBedard,not that great defensively...So he is notca goidcfot for what Hawksxrealky need upnfront...Needs more size plus 2 way pkay and ifbposdoble speed

This no braiberfor forwards=Cenebrini and LINdstron as 1stcandc2nd on a forwardctargetblist

.butbifvee pick 3rd or 4th after lotto...goita take other needs because nothing else at forward fits that high after Celebrini and Lindstrom off the boardvat top of draft ..so otherneddsxas IbsaidxarexRD
..but itwoukd be so hard to deny the size the skating ability and the shutdown ability of Sam Dickinson as a LD..Ifvyou had Dickinson and Vlasic as too 2cLD then add Ethan Del Masyron as 3rd LD...it would give the Hawks at leastx1 side of the D as the brst left sided-corps in the NHL ..D...In that case ,we still havexRDvisdues...namely replacing slow Murphy who also brings no offense,$9.5...who is not worth half that,and the meh others like Zaitsev or Phillips in his wrong side trying to fill a RD role.or Crevier who at bestvis onlyva 3RD ..If we can downscale $9.5 to a 2RD and find a 1RD

In any case even though we
Need either axRD to move $9.5 down to 2RD
..or we at least need a 2RD to bear more effective than a Murphy both in shutdown and I offensive contribution,that matters to wait if Dickinson is deemed too good to not take should ourctop 2 forward targets be already off the board when we pick.

Maybe ...depending on if hecstill is on the board with our TB pick in round one then we take a RD in Carter Yakemchuk (we could also try to movevup to get him a few picks earlier (early teens as opposed to latec teens).

It would be dissaliubtibg not to get sone top forwards i round one...vutcwe have no control on winnibg the #1or#2 spios via lottery..Luck
Will decide that.

Let us hope we at least get the #3 or#4 at worst lotto result.

If Hawks did go Dickinson at #3or#4 and if we coukd not get Yakemchuk witbthe TB pick then if Dean Letourneau is still o the board with that pick,we have to grab hom as aBig C potential 2C solution to contrast with the smallC Bedard is...Nazar would have to pkaycwing.

There is no way we pjayc2 small centers as our #1and#2Centers..

It will be interesting to see how KD decides after he knows where the lottery places us ...we need a lot if holes to fill..

Besides the draft there also is free agency ...both NHL fee agents and college free agents to help fill roles or lackingbs of our current team faster thatcwaiting for draftees to develop,mature and be "ready" to be NHL pros with actual competency.
 

Ace Card Bedard

Back in Black, Red, and White
Feb 11, 2012
9,078
4,067
Tampa currently 1 spot out of the last wild card in the East.
Let's pray they stay there.
 

Chuck Testa

Registered User
Mar 27, 2017
1,483
1,349
Wouldn't it be insane if they win the lotto again this year ;).

Worst case scenario they finish 3rd worst and drop to 5.
 

u2wojo

Registered User
Dec 22, 2011
957
745
Go by points percentage, not points.
This!!

Tampa is tied with Detroit for the 12th worse Pt% in the league. 6 teams are within 2pts of Tampa with games in hand (some as many as many as 4 fewer games played. 2 (Edmonton/Kraken) of those are in the Pacific where you get more cracks at San Jose, Anaheim, & Calgary
 

Rooh

GENERATIONAL TANK COMMANDER
Jul 4, 2017
3,781
9,470
Where is @Rooh when we need him most!? Please give us a new prophecy of hope.
fe5e1fc56b131b0c99d8259145d54f0d.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad