The bolded is exactly my problem. It’s a huge IF.
Up until this week, Lowry has never even been mentioned in the same breath as “2C”. Hell, I remember the days when people thought he was essentially a 4C and nothing more. I get he has looked capable in that role for a few games, but as you said, I think the absolute max upside for him is as a 40-45 point scorer. I feel like we’re reverting back to the days when Nik Antropov and/or Olli Jokinen were filling that role!
Bottom line, IMO we need a forward reinforcement that is universally viewed and rates out as a top 6 scorer. As I said, I would settle for a utility F that can play wing and pivot. Ideally it’s a natural C.