2024-2025 Blues Multi-Purpose Thread.

BlueMed

Registered User
Jul 18, 2019
2,887
3,464
Physically peak, that means about as healthy and in as good of shape as you can get. It's most definitely going to have an effect on recovery time. Muscle recovery especially.
Physically peak referring to cardiovascular fitness measured by VO2 max, physical strength, or body fat percentage? I'm not aware of any evidence that any of those metrics have been shown to improve recovery time of lower extremity fractures. Do you have any studies on this?
 

Xerloris

reckless optimism
Jun 9, 2015
7,586
8,207
St.Louis
Physically peak referring to cardiovascular fitness measured by VO2 max, physical strength, or body fat percentage? I'm not aware of any evidence (and I highly doubt) that any of those metrics have been shown to improve recovery time of lower extremity fractures. Do you have any studies on this?

Are you only reading like 3 or 4 words of what I say?
 

BlueMed

Registered User
Jul 18, 2019
2,887
3,464
Are you only reading like 3 or 4 words of what I say?
"Healthy" and "as good shape as you can get" are actually quite vague, which is why I asked what you meant specifically. There is no single metric or variable that defines what "healthy" or "good shape" means.
 

ChicagoBlues

Terraformers
Oct 24, 2006
15,472
6,445
"Healthy" and "as good shape as you can get" are actually quite vague, which is why I asked what you meant specifically. There is no single metric or variable that defines what "healthy" or "good shape" means.
I understand what Xerloris is saying, but I'm in my mid-50s and run circles around most 25 year olds.

A great attitude and lots of laughing go a long way.
 

BlueMed

Registered User
Jul 18, 2019
2,887
3,464
There are lots of injuries deemed 'ankle fractures' that are much less serious than breaking your tibia and fibula. Jack Roslovic returned 6 weeks and 4 days after fracturing his ankle last season. I agree with you that most ankle fractures take much longer than 6 weeks to return to action. 6 weeks is very much optimistic given what we know and my guess is that we are talking about 8+ weeks.

But we don't know any of the details about his specific injury and there are scenarios where it was minor enough that he "only" has to stay off it for 4 weeks and then can begin strengthening the surrounding muscles while putting weight on it. We don't know whether it requires a surgery. 6 weeks in a boot/cast is pretty much the minimum following a surgery, but a small fracture that doesn't require surgery doesn't carry the same timelines.

My gut tells me that we probably don't see him until after Christmas, but the Blues have been cagey about using the term "will be re-evaluated in X time" for the last few years. Given how many times we've seen Blues returning right at the initial timeline, it appears that the Blues use that term to refer to the time they believe the player could be cleared to play.
Ankle fractures typically take between 6-12 weeks, so Roslovic coming back at 6 weeks doesn't mean he didn't have a breakage of his tibia/fibula. Recovery time usually depends on the size and extent of the breakage. It may have been a very mild one.
 

Spektre

Registered User
Apr 10, 2010
9,027
6,776
Krynn
Would you be ok with paying a 1st and a 3rd as compensation to sign Broberg?

It’s obviously still very early in the season but I asked the ? In the offseason. Would you now give up a middling 1st and 3rd in compensation for Broberg?

Kudos to Army for getting both guys but everything about Broberg seems legitimate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Itsnotatrap

BlueMed

Registered User
Jul 18, 2019
2,887
3,464
At this point, the comparison between Broberg and JBo may have been a bit conservative. Broberg appears to be quite a bit more offensively potent. His ability to carry the puck through the neutral zone and deep into the offensive zone commonly generates high percentage plays. He also has an underrated shot from the point that has good accuracy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mike Liut

Majorityof1

Registered User
Mar 6, 2014
8,863
7,711
Central Florida
It’s obviously still very early in the season but I asked the ? In the offseason. Would you now give up a middling 1st and 3rd in compensation for Broberg?

Kudos to Army for getting both guys but everything about Broberg seems legitimate.

Not our first this year with Thomas missing significant time. We still could be a lottery team and a top 5 pick is worth more than Broberg, even after an incredible small sample size to start the season.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad