This…just this…
Pick Michkov and wait. Don’t overthink.
It’s really a Montreal thing to think like that.
We pick first….it’s a bad year, we always pick top 5 on bad year
We can pick a generational talent at 5 for once….too risky
You have to take risk to win in life.
Just draft Michkov if he’s there….please
People are getting carried away with this. He’s got star potential - something like Kaprizov. I seriously doubt he ever becomes as good as guys like Patrick Kane or Kucherov, and nobody would ever call those two “generational”.
He also is flawed in more ways than one and carries plenty of bust risk, baggage, question marks, etc. I’d personally steer clear. I’m all for swinging for the fences most times, but there are just too many red flags with him that a lot of people on here seem to be ignoring.
We can safely assume that Bedard, Fantilli, and Carlsson are gone at 5th, so I’d take all of Smith, Leonard, and Benson over Michkov. All three are fantastic prospects with tremendous upside, and they don’t come with all the BS and uncertainty that Michkov does. Sure Michkov could end up as the best player out of the 3, but as time goes on, that seems less and less likely.
His stock hasn’t only fallen due to the geopolitical situation; it’s been intrinsic factors as well. A couple years ago, he was being talked about as being in competition with Bedard for 1st overall. That seems ridiculous now. If I’ve learned anything about prospects and scouting, it’s that these “fallers” leading up to a draft rarely end up being good picks.
One more thought: I don’t find Reinbacher appealing at all. He’s a vanilla prospect who’s potential has been exaggerated due to “playing against men”, ignoring the fact that he’s physically mature and the league he plays in is one of the weakest major pro leagues. He seems like the defenseman version of Kotkaniemi. I’d pass, especially when several of the other prospects are guaranteed to be available. This is the only pick that would piss me off out of the ones that are likely. The rest of the guys mentioned, I could live with, including Michkov if it’s a choice between him and Reinbacher.