Prospect Info: 2023 Draft Thread (Yotes picking #6 & #12)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Vinny Boombatz

formerly ctwin22
Mar 21, 2008
11,184
6,920
Chandler, AZ
It's clear that he is the 2nd best talent...but you have to wait 4yrs and there is always the possibility he doesn't come over and just takes huge $$ to stay in Russia.

I just wonder which top 5 team is going to take him?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Summer Rose

Grimes

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Jan 5, 2012
8,680
5,202
Tippet's Doghouse
cleanhits.substack.com
It's clear that he is the 2nd best talent...but you have to wait 4yrs and there is always the possibility he doesn't come over and just takes huge $$ to stay in Russia.

I just wonder which top 5 team is going to take him?
100%
Or the least likely but disastrous scenario the the conflict gets worse and Russians don't come over period. (Just to be clear I think this is highly unlikely but currently you cant say it's out of the realm of possibility).
 

hbk

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Feb 28, 2002
23,128
9,818
Visit site
I really can’t understand Smith over Benson. I think Benson is so clearly better at everything. Not as tall. And not a center. But a truly special and elite talent.
Positional bias likely. Smith has 1st line skills which as a C makes him attractive. I don’t like his work ethic.
 

rt

Clean Hits on Substack
For me, Benson vs Michkov & Carlsson is the argument. Smith is next on my list but he’s not even in that conversation. I would listen to Yager vs Smith. Or Barlow or Reinbacher or whoever.

But it's not...you feel he's better in every skill and there are people like me who feel Smith is better at everything except for the motor.
It’s not even close.

Smith v Yager is a debate. That I could get into the details and the back and forth. That’s a good conversation. Smith v Benson I really can’t even get into. There’s a huge gulf between them.
 

Heldig

Registered User
Apr 12, 2002
17,647
11,341
BC
Russian factor is real.

Michkov is on my do not draft list.

Benson is the straw that stirs the drink on the best team in the CHL. I would gladly take him over Michkov at this rate unless BM knows something.
 

Vinny Boombatz

formerly ctwin22
Mar 21, 2008
11,184
6,920
Chandler, AZ
For me, Benson vs Michkov & Carlsson is the argument. Smith is next on my list but he’s not even in that conversation. I would listen to Yager vs Smith. Or Barlow or Reinbacher or whoever.


It’s not even close.

Smith v Yager is a debate. That I could get into the details and the back and forth. That’s a good conversation. Smith v Benson I really can’t even get into. There’s a huge gulf between them.
Here are the publication choices
FC Hockey: Bedard/Fantilli/Michkov/Carlsson/Benson/Smith
Hockey News: Bedard/Fantilli/Carlsson/Michkov/Smith/Benson(9)
McKeens: Bedard/Fantilli/Carlsson/Michkov/Smith/Benson(7)
Central Scouting NA: Bedard/Fantilli/Smith/Benson(7)
Sportsnet: Bedard/Fantilli/Carlsson/Michkov/Smith/Benson
BobbyMac: Bedard/Fantilli/Carlsson/Michkov/Benson/Smith
Button: Bedard/Fantilli/Carlsson/Sale/Michkov/Smith/Benson(9)

So I don't think it's all that clear...clear to you maybe, but not to the myriad of scouting publications out there who clearly value Smith higher.
 

rt

Clean Hits on Substack
Here are the publication choices
FC Hockey: Bedard/Fantilli/Michkov/Carlsson/Benson/Smith
Hockey News: Bedard/Fantilli/Carlsson/Michkov/Smith/Benson(9)
McKeens: Bedard/Fantilli/Carlsson/Michkov/Smith/Benson(7)
Central Scouting NA: Bedard/Fantilli/Smith/Benson(7)
Sportsnet: Bedard/Fantilli/Carlsson/Michkov/Smith/Benson
BobbyMac: Bedard/Fantilli/Carlsson/Michkov/Benson/Smith
Button: Bedard/Fantilli/Carlsson/Sale/Michkov/Smith/Benson(9)

So I don't think it's all that clear...clear to you maybe, but not to the myriad of scouting publications out there who clearly value Smith higher.
Benson is short. I won’t deny it.
 

lanky

Feeling Spicy
Jun 23, 2007
9,486
7,027
Winnipeg
ok, you got me, I'm sure "ALL" the publications are valuing him lower "only" because he's shorter.
The publications are always several months behind.
Benson has developed throughout the season into the dominant player that he is now. You'll see it fully reflected in the publications by May.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kaizen
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad