redacted
Registered User
- Feb 24, 2012
- 66,961
- 53,747
Aren't they all 30 (except PLD)?
Too old to win a Cup...
That's twisting that whole debate. The debate has never been that you can't have some players over 30 and win a Cup... nor that players over 30 can't contribute to winning a Cup. Because it is quite clear players over 30 can have a role, even major ones in winning. The argument has been around core players. Once the core gets old, you can't win Cups with them. Part of that is regression. Part of that that excess contract value deteriorates and thus depth on the team suffers. Old cores simply don't win Cups all that often. As a whole teams that are older, don't win Cups that much either. That doesn't mean you don't have 2-3-4 guys that are older on the team.
If you get a center over 30, they need to be playing at a high level and show they are still capable of the role. Ideally you're not tied into them for too long, but if they look like they'll still be an impact level player for 2-3 years, it's fine. To me a guy like ROR is a huge avoid as he is on a very clear downturn. But Schiefele... if you're talking a pure 1 year solution, he's about as talented and productive of a guy as you can expect.