The numbers prove it Chet. Johansen has been more productive throughout his career with twice as many 60+ point pace seasons, and 3 times as many actual 60+ point seasons with 6 to Kadri's 2.
His 26 goal 63 point season a couple years ago wasn't an outlier year either like you guys keep saying. He put up 63 points one other time and also had a 64 and 71 point season. He also had the same 26 goals one other time and a 33 goal season another.
This is not the same as Kadri's clear cut outlier year and career season, where he put up 87 points and paced for 100, which are both much higher than he ever had before.
I'll post it again in case you didn't see.
Kadri
2010-11: 34 pt pace
2011-12: 27 pt pace
2012-13: 75 pt pace (44 points)
2013-14: 53 pt pace
2014-15: 44 pt pace
2015-16: 49 pt pace
2016-17: 61 pt pace (61 points)
2017-18: 56 pt pace (55 points)
2018-19: 49 pt pace
2019-20: 58 pt pace (Avs)
2020-21: 47 pt pace (Avs)
2021-22: 100 pt pace (Avs) (87 points)
2022-23: 56 pt pace (56 points)
Johansen
2011-12: 26 pt pace
2012-13: 25 pt pace
2013-14: 63 pt pace (63 points)
2014-15: 71 pt pace (71 points)
2015-16: 62 pt pace (60 points)
2016-17: 61 pt pace (61 points)
2017-18: 56 pt pace
2018-19: 66 pt pace (64 points)
2019-20: 43 pt pace
2020-21: 38 pt pace
2021-22: 65 pt pace (63 points)
2022-23: 42 pt pace
You are skewing the data to make it fit your viewpoint. You're saying RyJo is better because over the years he was more consistent 60 pts guy. When he really has only had one good 60 pts season since 2019.
The last time RyJo out paced Kadri was 18-19, that's 5 seasons ago.
You can talk about throwing out outliers etc all you want but that still doesn't paint a picture of RyJo being better current day.
RyJo was better in the years 2012-2019, Kadri had been the better player the last 4 seasons, and honestly much better.
What RyJo did in his early to mid 20s isn't really relevant to the player he is today.
You can interpret the data however you want, but it doesn't really suggest that RyJo is better than Kadri current day. I think most on here would agree with me in saying Kadri is better today than RyJo and would take him 10 times out of 10 over RyJo.