I don't get the people that complain that the roster is soft, then preferred another skill guy to Gaucher. He is exactly what this team needs.
Since the first round is the only place to find a player like that.
Both are true.
.
=== LotR Version ===
Read at your own risk!
We're lacking top-6 forward talent when looking forward and usually top-6 talent are nabbed in the first round. In the AHL, Perreault and Tracey aren't highly praised to be future NHL'ers. Not in the AHL, the Ducks are trying to bank on quicksand Pastujov and the enigma of Colangelo.
Gaucher has a high floor to make the NHL, but that ceiling may not be high (limited to bottom-6 role). At the rookie exhibition, Gaucher showed he's a willing and aggressive pugilist. Gaucher has great straight line speed and can score. He's like a scoring Max Jones who can't turn on a dime, but be a better figher. Max Jones was a late first round pick as well.
There were other prospects that have higher ceilings such as C Lambert, C Kulich, RW Snuggerud, or RW Yurov.
22. C Gaucher: 6'3 and 207 lbs
23. RW Snuggerud: 6'1 and 188 lbs
24. RW Yurov: 6'1 and 178 lbs
28. C Kulich: 6'0 and 182 lbs
31. C Lambert: 6'0 and 183 lbs
The context needed would be, "Does Verbeek think we have the type of bottom-6 player like Gaucher in our system?" I thought we already did with both C Groulx and C Lopina, but Verbeek does not. Maybe Verbeek thinks there's a higher ceiling to Gaucher. Oddly, many on this board think Gaucher's path to the NHL will be at wing.
It's a bit weird on the selection of Gaucher considering how many picks we have this past draft and next past draft. There are potential top-6 talents drafted behind Gaucher. Grabbing top-6 potential with extra picks makes a lot of sense to take a swing on since top-6 forwards can sway games more than bottom-6 players. I think Verbeek went conservative with his first forward selection and wanted an NHL product into the future.
Right now, Gaucher seems to be blossoming a bit more. Maybe being a part of the WJC-20 team Canada helped him see the game differently. Gaucher's producing. Can't complain right now. We can look back at this pick years from now. At this early point, it looks like Verbeek did well.